I find it positive that employees can maintain their personal data in the digital personnel file themselves. This facilitates master data management and reduces administrative effort in everyday HR life.
I would also like to particularly highlight Jessyca Elendu, who supported us during our last Personio integration. She was always easily reachable, responded quickly, and supported us competently and solution-oriented. This is exactly the kind of personal support I would generally wish for from Personio. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.
What I don't like about Personio is mainly the difference between the promise to simplify HR processes and the actual administrative effort in everyday life. Many functions are fundamentally useful, but in practical application, they are unnecessarily complicated, inflexible, or associated with additional control effort.
Reporting and evaluations:
The reporting options are one of the biggest weaknesses for me. There is a lack of flexible, individually configurable reports that can be created without complicated detours.
Specific example: the evaluation of overtime balances on a specific historical date. A fundamentally basic HR evaluation, such as for the formation of provisions, cannot be reliably created without further ado. Instead, I have to combine various reports, trace calculations, and manually verify results. In some cases, values are generated that do not match the actual overtime balances.
I wish for significantly more flexible reporting options, comprehensible calculation logics, and reliable historical evaluations.
Customer service and personal support:
The loss of individual customer service is a huge step backward for me. I have been using Personio since 2017 and therefore have a long comparison period. In the past, I could contact support directly for specific problems. Today, there are almost only AI-supported assistance and a ticket system.
Especially with complex problems, general help center articles often do not help and cause frustration. Instead of an individual problem analysis, I sometimes receive standardized answers, even though the described problem is much more specific.
Also very cumbersome and a major point of frustration: that Personio increasingly relies on a community where HR managers/Personio users are supposed to support each other with technical problems and application questions. The exchange with other users can certainly be helpful, but it absolutely does not replace professional customer support for me. I pay for a software solution and expect the provider to competently support and provide solutions in case of problems. Instead, it gives the impression that the responsibility for problem-solving is increasingly being shifted to the customers themselves.
In addition, there are frequently changing contact persons, especially in account management. As a result, continuity is lacking, already described problems have to be explained again, and long-term support is hardly recognizable.
Technical problems and lack of cause analysis:
In time tracking, we have repeatedly experienced that time bookings were not transferred correctly, breaks or working times were displayed incorrectly, or bookings were missing despite successful recording.
Clarifying such errors was often lengthy, and we often simply gave up. Instead of a sustainable cause analysis, we repeatedly had to document, control, and correct individual cases. It was sometimes unclear where the errors actually occurred in the data transfer. However, the blame was gladly shifted to the middleware provider.
This is particularly annoying because a digital HR solution should actually help reduce manual controls and error corrections.
Time tracking and integration of external systems:
We use time tracking very intensively because, as a communication agency, we have to record project times in addition to regular working hours.
Since Personio does not fully meet our requirements for integrated time and project time tracking, we additionally need Halion Clock:it as middleware for data transfer.
This system landscape is technically complex, error-prone, and causes additional coordination and control effort.
I find it particularly inflexible that there is no suitable way to temporarily suspend time tracking in Personio if necessary, without affecting existing processes or historical data. Especially in the case of technical difficulties or a change of time tracking solution, such an option would be helpful.
Interfaces and DATEV integration:
Setting up our DATEV interface was also associated with considerable effort and long waiting times. Despite repeated inquiries, the implementation dragged on for weeks without us being reliably informed about the processing status.
In ongoing operations, there are also challenges in transferring and assigning historical and current personnel data, for example, when changing employment relationships. It is not always immediately clear how data is transferred and where possible errors occur.
I expect from a paid interface not only the technical transfer of data but also a comprehensible setup, reliable processes, and competent support in case of problems.
Permissions and role management:
I also find the management of access rights unnecessarily complex and not very intuitive.
When administrative HR tasks are to be delegated to colleagues, it is extremely time-consuming to set up the appropriate permissions. The multitude of individual settings makes it difficult to keep track and ensure that employees receive exactly the accesses they need for their tasks - no more and no less.
Here, I wish for more understandable permission groups, practical role templates, and above all, a clear presentation of which accesses are actually associated with a particular role.
Rigid packages and limited customization:
The rigid product packages do not always fit the individual requirements of a company. Certain functions or technical possibilities are tied to packages, even though only individual components are needed.
I find it particularly annoying that we can no longer set up individual API connections in our core package, although this option was still available until recently. Especially when companies are already working with specialized systems, flexible integrations should be possible without having to book a more extensive package.
Pricing and billing:
I find the pricing overall not very flexible. Additionally, we have already had the case that services or modules were billed twice, and we had to initiate the clarification ourselves.
For a system that forms an essential part of our HR infrastructure, I expect transparent and comprehensible billing.
My overall conclusion:
Personio offers many functions that are fundamentally useful for digital HR work. However, in daily use, I miss flexibility, reliability, and individual support in crucial areas.
It is particularly frustrating that we, as customers, have to invest a lot of time in troubleshooting, data control, developing workarounds, and communicating with support. This creates additional administrative effort, even though the software should actually reduce this.
I wish that Personio would again focus more on the actual workflows and needs of its customers. Instead of offering more and more functions, I believe that the basic processes should first work reliably, intuitively, and flexibly.
And above all, I wish for a customer service where you feel that someone personally takes responsibility for solving a problem. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.
Hallo Kristin,
vielen Dank für Ihr ausführliches und ehrliches Feedback und dafür, dass Sie Personio seit 2017 begleiten. Wir freuen uns über das Lob für Jessyca und geben es gern intern weiter.
Danke auch für Ihr ausführliches Produkt-Feedback. Ihre genannten Punkte sind intern bekannt und an Lösungen wird gearbeitet.
Ihre Erfahrungen zum Support nehmen wir sehr ernst. Sie entsprechen nicht den Standards, die wir uns setzen. Unser Team arbeitet stetig an Erweiterungen und Verbesserungen der gesamten Support-Erfahrung; KI-Unterstützt und menschlich. Unser Ziel ist schnellstmögliche Sofort-Hilfe bei allgemeinen Anliegen und schnelle persönliche Hilfe bei komplexen Anliegen.
Für die gemachten Erfahrungen und den entstandenen Frust möchten wir uns entschuldigen.
Ihre Beschreibung enthält auch viel Positives, etwa die Selbstpflege der Daten durch Mitarbeitende und die Lohnvorbereitung über DATEV. Wir würden gern verstehen, was für Sie schlussendlich den Ausschlag für einen Stern gegeben hat. Wir werden bei Ihnen nach Kontaktinformationen nachfragen, damit wir uns zentral bei Ihnen melden, den genannten Themen widmen und die Fälle intern aufarbeiten können.
Mit freundlichen Grüßen
Ihr Personio Team



