
First of all, the software does work and is active. There are new versions every year, which is reassuring. We've been using AMember for 10 years. At the time, it was the only subscription software that worked with Joomla, so we had to go with it, and they haven't disappeared like so many web developers who make plugins. It's also inexpensive, which is both good and bad. We WISH it cost more so it could be a higher-end product, if that makes sense.
But it has evolved, I have to say, and it has become more sophisticated. We use a lot of integrations: Stripe and PayPal for payments. Google Analytics for ecommerce tracking. ActiveCampaign so that we can have a Members-only newsletter.
Their documentation is a little bare, but the fact that these integrations actually went smoothly was a pleasant surprise. The back-end doesn't look too bad, either - it's easy to navigate, and I prefer the simple look to something full of distractions. It's web software, we don't expect flashy interface behind the scenes.
If you're using Joomla, though, it still may be the only choice available to you. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.
1) You can't customize the order and checkout pages. They are bare bones and look like basic HTML, which I guess is fine once they get to the payment stage. You don't need an order form to be flashy, especially for a fiction journal. Still, there are things we would have liked to include on this page (links to help, privacy statement, etc) that we simply cannot do because it would mean altering the template, and we're not programmers.
2) This is the big huge one, the reason we would have switched if there wasn't any other membership software that worked with Joomla. You can't ADD ON to an existing subscription manually.
Every year, we have a 50% off subscriptions sale (we're an online fiction magazine). So, we create a coupon for this, which is easy to do. But CURRENT subscribers have no way of adding on this extra year at 50% off to their subscription. Instead, if they use the coupon, AMember takes out a SECOND account and they get *double billed.* This has caused us headaches in the past, and we simply disallow use of the coupon if someone has a current subscription. But we'd love for the software to just be able to extend the subscription. So, if someone was subbed for 3 months, they could ADD ON and subscribe for 15 months.
3) There's no spam-registration filtering. So obvious fake accounts with repetitive names like "TireMuscle TireMuscle" still count as 'registrations' even though they're under Pending members (people who haven't confirmed.) Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.
Validated through Google using a business email account
This reviewer was offered a nominal gift card as thank you for completing this review.
Invitation from G2. This reviewer was offered a nominal gift card as thank you for completing this review.

