Highest Rated Payroll Services

2026 Best Software Awards are here!See the list

The Top 9 Payroll Services

Collapse AllExpand All

G2 Satisfaction Score

Compare

G&A Partners Services

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Construction

31%

Financial Services

23%

Non-Profit Organization Management

23%

Manufacturing

23%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

9.6

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

9.4

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

9.7

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

9.3

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

9.4

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

9.6

CoAdvantage

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Manufacturing

28%

Real Estate

28%

Automotive

22%

Construction

22%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

9.2

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

9.4

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

9.6

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

9.3

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

9.4

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

9.4

MSA

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Staffing and Recruiting

29%

Textiles

29%

Logistics and Supply Chain

29%

Consumer Goods

14%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

9.9

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

9.6

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

9.8

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

9.4

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

9.4

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

9.8

ADP Payroll Services

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Retail

30%

Hospital & Health Care

30%

Computer Software

21%

Education Management

20%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

8.5

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

8.3

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

8.7

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

8.4

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

8.4

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

8.4

INS Global

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Wine and Spirits

30%

Construction

30%

Computer Software

20%

Business Supplies and Equipment

20%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

9.1

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

9.4

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

10.0

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

9.9

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

9.1

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

9.1

JeonSoft

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Financial Services

92%

Logistics and Supply Chain

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

9.7

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

9.6

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

9.7

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

9.6

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

9.6

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

9.6

Insperity

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Computer Software

33%

Non-Profit Organization Management

28%

Information Technology and Services

22%

Education Management

17%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

9.0

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

8.4

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

9.1

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

8.8

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

8.2

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

9.0

OneSource Virtual

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Automotive

25%

Biotechnology

25%

Chemicals

25%

Accounting

25%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

9.7

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

9.4

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

9.8

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

9.8

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

8.9

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

9.7

Execupay

Overall Satisfaction Score

Top Industries of Reviewers:

Accounting

43%

Health, Wellness and Fitness

29%

Computer & Network Security

14%

Construction

14%

Ratings from Reviews (out of 10):

Ease of Doing Business With

Average: 9.2

7.7

Communication Skills

Average: 9.0

7.6

Professionalism

Average: 9.4

7.8

Responsiveness

Average: 9.1

7.2

Execution Ability

Average: 8.9

7.2

Expertise of Team

Average: 9.1

7.6