User Satisfaction Ratings
All reviews were collected as of May 03, 2026 Fingercheck (360) 4.7 out of 5 Fingercheck |  Paychex (1,677) 4.1 out of 5 Paychex | |
| Star Rating | Fingercheck 360 reviews | Paychex 1,677 reviews |
Reviews
Ease of Admin
Fingercheck
Responses: 251
Paychex
Responses: 990
Ease of Setup
Fingercheck
Responses: 253
Paychex
Responses: 1012
Ease of Use
Fingercheck
Responses: 297
Paychex
Responses: 1403
Has the product been a good partner in doing business?
Fingercheck
Responses: 250
Paychex
Responses: 987
Likelihood to Recommend
Fingercheck
Responses: 351
Paychex
Responses: 1645
Avg. Go Live Time (months)
Fingercheck
Average 1 Months
Paychex
Average 2 Months
Product Direction (% positive)
Fingercheck
Responses: 289
Paychex
Responses: 1315
Meets Requirements
Fingercheck
Responses: 293
Paychex
Responses: 1340
Quality of Support
Fingercheck
Responses: 292
Paychex
Responses: 1293
Avg. ROI (months)
Fingercheck
Average 10 Months
Paychex
Average 16 Months
AI Text Generation
Fingercheck
Responses: 17
Paychex
Responses: 12
AI Text Summarization
Fingercheck
Responses: 17
Paychex
Responses: 12
AI Text Summarization
Fingercheck
Responses: 17
Paychex
Responses: 9
API / Integration
Fingercheck
Responses: 115
Paychex
Responses: 265
Accounting Integration
Fingercheck
Responses: 126
Paychex
Responses: 305
Approvals
Fingercheck
Responses: 137
Paychex
Responses: 456
Automatic Tax Payment
Fingercheck
Responses: 157
Paychex
Responses: 830
Benefits Manager
Fingercheck
Responses: 129
Paychex
Responses: 548
Check/W-2 Delivery
Fingercheck
Responses: 140
Paychex
Responses: 832
Check/W-2 Printing
Fingercheck
Responses: 156
Paychex
Responses: 782
Core HR Integration
Fingercheck
Responses: 113
Paychex
Responses: 264
Direct Deposit
Fingercheck
Responses: 169
Paychex
Responses: 934
Expense Reimbursement
Fingercheck
Responses: 127
Paychex
Responses: 407
Mobile
Fingercheck
Responses: 161
Paychex
Responses: 528
Payroll Entry
Fingercheck
Responses: 182
Paychex
Responses: 874
Performance and Reliability
Fingercheck
Responses: 171
Paychex
Responses: 884
Pre-tax Deductions
Fingercheck
Responses: 149
Paychex
Responses: 783
Payroll Reporting
Fingercheck
Responses: 175
Paychex
Responses: 866
Scalability
Fingercheck
Responses: 160
Paychex
Responses: 728
Tax Calculation
Fingercheck
Responses: 165
Paychex
Responses: 882
Tax Filing
Fingercheck
Responses: 157
Paychex
Responses: 839
Time Off Accrual
Fingercheck
Responses: 159
Paychex
Responses: 563
Time Tracking Integration
Fingercheck
Responses: 134
Paychex
Responses: 302
User, Role, and Access Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 174
Paychex
Responses: 841
Wage Garnishment
Fingercheck
Responses: 128
Paychex
Responses: 564
Web Portal
Fingercheck
Responses: 174
Paychex
Responses: 855
AI Text Summarization
Fingercheck
Responses: 15
Paychex
Responses: 5
Benefits Administration
Fingercheck
Responses: 48
Paychex
Responses: 114
Compliance
Fingercheck
Responses: 52
Paychex
Responses: 113
Expense Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 50
Paychex
Responses: 52
Organization Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 39
Paychex
Responses: 113
Salary Structures
Fingercheck
Responses: 46
Paychex
Responses: 76
Time, Attendance, and PTO
Fingercheck
Responses: 61
Paychex
Responses: 106
Automated Onboarding Workflows
Fingercheck
Responses: 76
Paychex
Responses: 82
Automated Team Introductions
Fingercheck
Responses: 68
Paychex
Responses: 51
Background Checks
Fingercheck
Responses: 62
Paychex
Responses: 47
Compliance Training
Fingercheck
Responses: 64
Paychex
Responses: 60
E-Forms
Fingercheck
Responses: 76
Paychex
Responses: 114
E-Signature
Fingercheck
Responses: 79
Paychex
Responses: 95
Forms Library
Fingercheck
Responses: 76
Paychex
Responses: 106
Interview Scheduling
Fingercheck
Responses: 63
Paychex
Responses: 49
Offer Letter Approvals
Fingercheck
Responses: 63
Paychex
Responses: 46
Offer Letter Templates
Fingercheck
Responses: 61
Paychex
Responses: 45
Onboarding
Fingercheck
Responses: 87
Paychex
Responses: 116
Onboarding Notifications
Fingercheck
Responses: 81
Paychex
Responses: 100
Onboarding Process Reporting
Fingercheck
Responses: 79
Paychex
Responses: 77
Self-Service Portal
Fingercheck
Responses: 83
Paychex
Responses: 129
Time-to-Productivity Reporting
Fingercheck
Responses: 70
Paychex
Responses: 56
Visualization
Fingercheck
Responses: 69
Paychex
Responses: 64
Customization
Fingercheck
Responses: 132
Paychex
Responses: 312
Activity Dashboard
Fingercheck
Responses: 134
Paychex
Responses: 423
Integration APIs
Fingercheck
Responses: 106
Paychex
Responses: 165
Internationalization
Fingercheck
Responses: 62
Paychex
Responses: 18
Mobility
Fingercheck
Responses: 130
Paychex
Responses: 292
Performance
Fingercheck
Responses: 135
Paychex
Responses: 409
Reporting
Fingercheck
Responses: 136
Paychex
Responses: 401
User, Role, and Access Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 136
Paychex
Responses: 400
AI Image-to-Text
Fingercheck
Responses: 14
Paychex
Responses: 14
AI Text Generation
Fingercheck
Responses: 14
Paychex
Responses: 14
AI Text Summarization
Fingercheck
Responses: 14
Paychex
Responses: 14
Benefits Dashboards
Fingercheck
Responses: 27
Paychex
Responses: 222
Integrations / APIs
Fingercheck
Responses: 28
Paychex
Responses: 101
Internationalization
Fingercheck
Responses: 19
Paychex
Responses: 19
Mobility
Fingercheck
Responses: 19
Paychex
Responses: 23
APIs / Integration
Fingercheck
Responses: 90
Paychex
Responses: 98
Automated Reminders
Fingercheck
Responses: 119
Paychex
Responses: 140
Billable Time Rate Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 127
Paychex
Responses: 94
Business Tool Integration
Fingercheck
Responses: 129
Paychex
Responses: 134
Ease of Completing Timesheets
Fingercheck
Responses: 174
Paychex
Responses: 217
Electronic Payments
Fingercheck
Responses: 98
Paychex
Responses: 82
Internationalization
Fingercheck
Responses: 59
Paychex
Responses: 34
Invoice Creation and Delivery
Fingercheck
Responses: 95
Paychex
Responses: 9
Mobile User Support
Fingercheck
Responses: 133
Paychex
Responses: 148
Offline
Fingercheck
Responses: 97
Paychex
Responses: 75
Performance and Reliability
Fingercheck
Responses: 144
Paychex
Responses: 207
Policy Compliance Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 113
Paychex
Responses: 130
Project Accounting / Revenue Recognition
Fingercheck
Responses: 91
Paychex
Responses: 75
Reporting
Fingercheck
Responses: 149
Paychex
Responses: 216
Project Time Tracking
Fingercheck
Responses: 146
Paychex
Responses: 150
Tracking Time to Project/Task
Fingercheck
Responses: 134
Paychex
Responses: 131
User, Role, and Access Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 151
Paychex
Responses: 198
Workflow
Fingercheck
Responses: 123
Paychex
Responses: 136
Benefits Record Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 36
Paychex
Responses: 233
Document Management
Fingercheck
Responses: 36
Paychex
Responses: 172
Enrollment Planning
Fingercheck
Responses: 32
Paychex
Responses: 196
Mobile Benefits Access
Fingercheck
Responses: 34
Paychex
Responses: 151
Regulatory Compliance
Fingercheck
Responses: 36
Paychex
Responses: 211
Self-Service Portal
Fingercheck
Responses: 37
Paychex
Responses: 226
Third-Party Carrier Integration
Fingercheck
Responses: 30
Paychex
Responses: 112
Total Compensation Statements
Fingercheck
Responses: 35
Paychex
Responses: 189
About G2
G2 is the world's largest and most trusted software marketplace. More than 90 million people annually — including employees at all Fortune 500 companies — use G2 to make smarter software decisions based on authentic peer reviews. Thousands of software and services companies of all sizes partner with G2 to build their reputation and grow their business.
Keeping our ratings unbiased is our top priority. We require the use of a LinkedIn account or verified business email address to validate a G2 user’s identity and employer. Additionally, all reviews are manually checked by our team. Only the opinion of real users and data from public sources factor into our ratings.
Hunting for software insights?
With over 3 million reviews, we can provide the specific details that help you make an informed software buying decision for your business. Finding the right product is important, let us help.
Your software and service insights are valuable.
Each experience you share helps millions of software buyers choose with confidence. Every review is published across G2 marketplaces: G2, Capterra, Software Advice, and GetApp.
Unlock your personalized comparison.
Adjust filters, set requirements, and get a G2 recommendation tailored to your team.
or continue with
By proceeding, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
By proceeding, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy