Best Email Deliverability Solutions - Page 9

How Many Email Deliverability Tools Products Does G2 Track?

Total Products under this Category: 251

Category Stats (Oct 2026)

  • Average Rating: 4.54/5 The average rating of products in this category, based on all submitted ratings
  • Top Trending Product: Artisan (+2.5%) - Among all products in this category, Artisan recorded the largest rating increase compared to last month

Last updated: October 21, 2026

How Does G2 Rank Email Deliverability Tools Products?

Why You Can Trust G2's Software Rankings:

  • 30 Analysts and Data Experts
  • 73,300+ Authentic Reviews
  • 251+ Products
  • Unbiased Rankings

G2's software rankings are built on verified user reviews, rigorous moderation, and a consistent research methodology maintained by a team of analysts and data experts. Each product is measured using the same transparent criteria, with no paid placement or vendor influence. While reviews reflect real user experiences, which can be subjective, they offer valuable insight into how software performs in the hands of professionals. Together, these inputs power the G2 Score, a standardized way to compare tools within every category.

G2 Grid® for Email Deliverability Tools

G2 Grid® for Email Deliverability Tools plotting products by satisfaction and market presence

Highlighted products: Constant Contact, lemlist, Instantly, Brevo, Apollo.io, Warmy, Klaviyo, and Intuit Mailchimp Email Marketing.

Underlying data: [Grid® JSON](https://www.g2.com/categories/email-deliverability/grids.json?focus%5B%5D=constant-contact&focus%5B%5D=lemlist&focus%5B%5D=instantly&focus%5B%5D=brevo-brevo&focus%5B%5D=apollo-io&focus%5B%5D=warmy&focus%5B%5D=klaviyo&focus%5B%5D=intuit-mailchimp-email-marketing)

EmailConsul

EmailConsul is an award-winning comprehensive solution for monitoring and optimizing email deliverability, enhancing inbox placement, and ensuring email authentication compliance. With over 20 years of experience in email deliverability, we understand the challenges that email marketers face in navigating the complexities of the ever-changing digital landscape. That's why we've developed EmailConsul to empower marketers with the tools and insights needed to succeed in their email marketing endeavours. KEY FEATURES AND DIFFERENTIATORS Advanced Deliverability Monitoring: EmailConsul offers a comprehensive suite of tools designed to elevate your email deliverability and protect your sender reputation. Our modular platform caters to your unique business needs, providing advanced monitoring and optimization solutions including: • DMARC Monitoring Gain actionable insights into your email authentication performance and combat phishing attacks with our DMARC monitoring solution. • Inbox Placement Tests Ensure your emails reach the inbox with confidence using our comprehensive inbox placement testing suite. • Domain & IP Blocklist Monitoring: Safeguard your domains and IPs by monitoring blacklist appearances in real-time, enabling proactive remediation. • Domain LookAlike Identify and prevent domain spoofing attacks with our domain lookalike detection feature. • Google & Microsoft Sender Reputation Data Access real-time sender reputation data from Google Postmaster and Microsoft SNDS to optimize inbox placement on major email platforms. • Authentication Monitoring Verify DNS entries to prevent accidental removals and ensure seamless email authentication. WHY CHOOSE EMAILCONSUL OVER COMPETITORS Performance: EmailConsul offers unparalleled performance and reliability, backed by advanced technology and industry-leading expertise. Affordability: We believe that email deliverability solutions should be accessible to businesses of all sizes. That's why we offer competitive and modular pricing plans tailored to meet your budgetary requirements without compromising on quality or functionality. Unmatched Customer Support: At EmailConsul, we prioritize the success of our customers. Our dedicated support team is available around the clock to provide expert guidance, troubleshoot issues, and offer strategic advice on improving email deliverability and authentication. We're committed to ensuring that you get the most out of our platform and achieve your email marketing goals. User-Friendly Interface: Our intuitive interface makes it easy for users of all skill levels to navigate the platform, analyze data, and take actionable steps to improve email deliverability and authentication. Comprehensive Solution: While other platforms may offer limited functionality, EmailConsul provides a comprehensive suite of tools for email deliverability monitoring, authentication, and optimization, ensuring that all your email marketing needs are met under one roof. Languages Supported: EmailConsul supports a wide range of languages to accommodate our global user base and facilitate seamless communication and collaboration.

Average Rating: 5.0/5.0

Total Reviews: 2

How Do G2 Users Rate EmailConsul?

  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind EmailConsul?

  • Seller: EmailConsul
  • Year Founded: 2021
  • HQ Location: New York, US
  • Twitter: @EmailConsul
    68 Twitter followers
  • LinkedIn® Page: www.linkedin.com
    7 employees on LinkedIn®

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Do G2 Reviewers Say About EmailConsul?

AI-generated summary from verified user reviews

Pros
  • Users value the detailed analytics of EmailConsul, providing valuable insights for error identification and diagnosis.
  • Users value the responsive support from EmailConsul, helping them quickly resolve issues and enhance platform usage.
  • Users value the reliability of EmailConsul, appreciating quick support and detailed insights for issue resolution.

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of EmailConsul?

Envoie

Envoie.email is an email marketing platform to create interactive emails that encourage users to take action within their inbox. Create, schedule, and send automated interactive emails or email sequences for getting customer feedback, booking appointments, onboarding, lead nurturing, outreach or re-engagement. Email features include interactive elements like checkout buttons, quizzes, star-ratings, webinar forms, calendars, etc. AMP emails are responsive to various browsers, email clients, and mobile devices, allowing marketers to increase visibility and email delivery. Manage email lists with customer segmentation. View campaign analytics and engagement rates in the dashboard. Integrate with Zapier, Webhooks, and other ESPs.

Average Rating: 4.2/5.0

Total Reviews: 3

How Do G2 Users Rate Envoie?

  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 8.3/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind Envoie?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 75% Small, 25% Medium

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of Envoie?

GreenArrow Engine

Everything you need for powerful email delivery is built in. We've taken care of the difficult details.

Average Rating: 3.4/5.0

Total Reviews: 4

How Do G2 Users Rate GreenArrow Engine?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)
  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind GreenArrow Engine?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 75% Small, 25% Large

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of GreenArrow Engine?

What Are G2 Users Discussing About GreenArrow Engine?

AI can help you find the answers. G2 helps you trust them.

Connect G2 to Claude or ChatGPT for answers grounded in G2's trusted reviews, comparisons, and pricing from real user insights.

How it works
Connect G2 to ChatGPTConnect G2 to Claude

InboxDoctor

InboxDoctor is a human-powered email warmup and AI based service designed to optimize email deliverability and inbox placement for B2B and B2C businesses, marketers, and email operations professionals. Our platform enables users to ensure their emails land in recipients’ inboxes rather than spam folders through features like scalable warmup campaigns, dedicated seed lists, spam trigger detection, inbox placement, email health tests and real-time analytics. We serve clients globally, from startups to enterprises, helping them build strong sender reputation, manage multiple mailboxes, and achieve high inbox placement rates for campaigns such as newsletters, cold outreach, and transactional emails.

Average Rating: 5.0/5.0

Total Reviews: 2

How Do G2 Users Rate InboxDoctor?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)
  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 9.2/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind InboxDoctor?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Do G2 Reviewers Say About InboxDoctor?

AI-generated summary from verified user reviews

Pros
  • Users appreciate the ease of use of InboxDoctor, simplifying email deliverability with clear visuals and smooth processes.
  • Users value the effective email warmup from InboxDoctor, enhancing deliverability and freeing up time for core activities.
  • Users value the human-powered warm-up model of InboxDoctor, enhancing sender reputation with trusted engagement signals.
  • Users value the real-time deliverability insights of InboxDoctor, which enhance sender reputation and proactive risk management.
  • Users value the simplified email deliverability management of InboxDoctor, enabling focus on product development and sales.
Cons
  • Users find the data import process time-consuming, especially with numerous mailboxes, despite support assistance.
  • Users find difficult navigation in InboxDoctor challenging, especially with the overwhelming amount of data and reports available.
  • Users struggle with insufficient training, highlighting a need for better onboarding and guided navigation in InboxDoctor.
  • Users find a steep learning curve with InboxDoctor, requiring time to adapt to its detailed data analytics.

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of InboxDoctor?

InboxIgniter

InboxIgniter.com is a revolutionary email warmup tool. You can simply connect your mailbox you want to run outreach campaigns with and the tool will take care of everything by itself. Inboxigniter is an AI-powered email warmup tool that works by taking care of industries, business niches, languages and locations to give the best results.

Average Rating: 4.8/5.0

Total Reviews: 8

How Do G2 Users Rate InboxIgniter?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)
  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 9.2/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 8.3/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind InboxIgniter?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 38% Large, 38% Small

What Do G2 Reviewers Say About InboxIgniter?

AI-generated summary from verified user reviews

Pros
  • Users value how InboxIgniter makes email marketing effortless, enhancing engagement and significantly boosting conversions.
  • Users praise the ease of use of InboxIgniter, appreciating its straightforward interface and powerful automation tools.
  • Users value the email warm-up feature of InboxIgniter for enhancing deliverability and optimizing campaign success.
  • Users value the ease of email management with InboxIgniter, ensuring messages reach the right audience effortlessly.
  • Users value the analytics capabilities of InboxIgniter, effectively optimizing email campaigns and enhancing performance insights.
Cons
  • Users desire more customization options in InboxIgniter, feeling it restricts flexibility for advanced campaign tracking.
  • Users find the limited features of InboxIgniter restrict customization and integration, impacting overall usability and flexibility.
  • Users feel the limited customization options of InboxIgniter restrict flexibility, especially for advanced users.
  • Users report missing features like API integration, mobile app, free trial, and advanced filtering options.
  • Users experience occasional dashboard loading delays and desire more customization options for improved campaign tracking.

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of InboxIgniter?

MailChannels Outbound Filtering

Inbound and outbound email security solutions for internet infrastructure providers.

Average Rating: 3.3/5.0

Total Reviews: 2

How Do G2 Users Rate MailChannels Outbound Filtering?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 5.0/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)

Who Is the Company Behind MailChannels Outbound Filtering?

  • Seller: MailChannels
  • Year Founded: 2004
  • HQ Location: Vancouver, CA
  • Twitter: @mailchannels
    2,493 Twitter followers
  • LinkedIn® Page: www.linkedin.com
    22 employees on LinkedIn®
  • Ownership: Privately-held

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 50% Medium, 50% Small

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of MailChannels Outbound Filtering?

MailerLogic

MailerLogic is a modern alternative to SendGrid, Mailgun, and Postmark. Send transactional and marketing emails via SMTP or API with built-in stream separation and deliverability intelligence. Analyze health, engagement, risk, and content quality before sending. Includes CRM, automation, campaigns, and 260+ APIs. Send emails and make sure they land.

Average Rating: 4.8/5.0

Total Reviews: 2

How Do G2 Users Rate MailerLogic?

  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)

Who Is the Company Behind MailerLogic?

  • Seller: BrainCert
  • Year Founded: 2013
  • HQ Location: Herndon, Virginia
  • Twitter: @BrainCert
    4,446 Twitter followers
  • LinkedIn® Page: www.linkedin.com
    26 employees on LinkedIn®

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of MailerLogic?

Mailora

Mailora is a modern inbox placement and email deliverability intelligence platform designed for marketing and email operations teams who demand clarity, speed, and results. Built for the next generation of digital communication, Mailora helps businesses ensure their emails land where they belong, the inbox, across global ISPs, devices, and user contexts. 💡 What We Do At Mailora, we empower email teams to understand why deliverability fails — and what to do about it. We go beyond basic inbox testing to deliver: ✅ Inbox Placement Testing – Real-time insights on whether your emails land in inbox, spam, or promotions across dozens of international ISPs. ✅ Spam Filter Diagnostics – Deep analysis of what triggers spam filters, including content patterns, HTML issues, and authentication mismatches. ✅ Sender Reputation Monitoring – Ongoing tracking of your domain, IP, and email authentication health (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI). ✅ Multivariate Testing (MVT) – A/B/C testing for email components like subject lines, headers, sender names, and body copy to optimize for inbox performance. ✅ Visual Reports & Alerts – Intuitive dashboards, smart alerts, and actionable recommendations — not just data dumps. 👥 Who We Serve We’re built for: Growth-stage SaaS companies E-commerce and DTC brands B2B service based companies Deliverability consultants and agencies High-volume senders using ESPs like Postmark, Klaviyo, SendGrid, or Ongage 🌍 Our Difference Unlike legacy deliverability tools, Mailora offers: A modern, clutter-free interface Intelligent diagnostics instead of raw seed data Global ISP coverage and fast test results Flexible APIs and integrations (coming soon) We're not just helping teams monitor deliverability, we're helping them improve it with clarity and confidence.

Average Rating: 4.8/5.0

Total Reviews: 2

How Do G2 Users Rate Mailora?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)
  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)

Who Is the Company Behind Mailora?

  • Seller: Mailora
  • Year Founded: 2025
  • HQ Location: Cheyenne, US
  • LinkedIn® Page: www.linkedin.com
    8 employees on LinkedIn®

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 50% Small, 50% Medium

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of Mailora?

Mailtarget

Mailtarget is email infrastructure built for enterprise in Southeast Asia. We run two core products: - Email API for reliable transactional email delivery, and - Email Marketing for personalized, automated campaigns. # WHO USES MAILTARGET Enterprise teams in regulated industries: banking, fintech, telco, insurance, and government. Our clients include 17+ banks in Indonesia, including institutions under active OJK oversight. We also serve large enterprise tech companies with high-volume transactional sending needs. # WHY ENTERPRISE TEAMS CHOOSE US - Local servers. Data stays in Indonesia, no cross-border transit. For regulated industries where data residency is a compliance requirement, this is not optional. - ISO 27001 certified. Our security practices meet the international standard. Recognized by auditors. Required by procurement teams in regulated sectors. - Own MTA infrastructure. That means we control routing, retry logic, queue management, and deliverability, not a vendor above us. - Dedicated infrastructure. Dedicated IP pools, granular routing rules, priority queuing, and retry logic. Your sending reputation stays separate from other senders. - Full API access. Every feature is accessible via API. Real-time delivery events via webhooks. Built for developers who need deep integration into existing systems. - Deep observability. Inbox placement per ISP, bounce breakdown, delivery rate monitoring, complaint tracking, with timestamps and error codes, not just "sent" and "failed." - Local support. Our team is in Indonesia. Same timezone. Same language. Reachable during your business hours. - Rupiah pricing. No currency risk. No conversion overhead. Predictable costs for Indonesian enterprises. # DEPLOYMENT OPTIONS Cloud, hybrid, or full on-premise. For banks and government institutions that cannot allow data to leave their network, we offer full on-premise MTA deployment. This is a deployment option that no global provider currently offers for the Indonesian market. If email failure has real business consequences, that is the use case we are built for.

Average Rating: 4.3/5.0

Total Reviews: 3

How Do G2 Users Rate Mailtarget?

  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)

Who Is the Company Behind Mailtarget?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 67% Small, 33% Medium

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of Mailtarget?

MDirector

MDirector is an all-in-one platform for SMS & Email Marketing, Automation, and Landing Pages to boost campaigns and digital presence. It excels in audience personalization and segmentation, enabling more targeted and effective campaigns. Key features include workflow automation, detailed campaign performance analysis, and integration with other platforms to enhance user experience and marketing outcomes. MDirector also allows the creation of forms, landing pages, and database management, all through an intuitive interface. This all-in-one tool is designed to improve communication, streamline customer acquisition, and boost digital presence, making it ideal for businesses seeking to strengthen customer relationships and enhance marketing performance.

Average Rating: 4.5/5.0

Total Reviews: 4

How Do G2 Users Rate MDirector?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)
  • Campaign Performance: 9.2/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind MDirector?

  • Seller: MDirector
  • Year Founded: 2007
  • HQ Location: Madrid, ES
  • Twitter: @emailMDirector
    2,222 Twitter followers
  • LinkedIn® Page: www.linkedin.com
    12 employees on LinkedIn®

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 50% Medium, 50% Small

What Do G2 Reviewers Say About MDirector?

AI-generated summary from verified user reviews

Pros
  • Users value the clear analytics of MDirector, which optimize campaign performance and enhance targeting effectiveness.
  • Users value MDirector's multichannel campaign management, simplifying email and SMS marketing integration with effective targeting and insights.
  • Users value the clear analytics of MDirector, enabling effective optimization of their multichannel marketing campaigns.
  • Users value the ease of use of MDirector, simplifying multichannel campaign management with a user-friendly interface.
  • Users value the easy creation of multichannel campaigns with MDirector, simplifying marketing efforts on one platform.
Cons
  • Users find the lack of integrations with external CRMs and e-commerce platforms limits MDirector’s overall usability.
  • Users find limited features in MDirector, particularly in CRM integrations and SMS template customization options.
  • Users note limited options for external integrations and customization, hindering the full potential of MDirector.
  • Users find the limited templates in MDirector restrict customization, impacting the effectiveness of their campaigns.
  • Users find that SMS template customization and CRM integrations could be improved for a smoother experience with MDirector.

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of MDirector?

What Are G2 Users Discussing About MDirector?

Reachkit

Reachkit is a cold email outreach platform that helps businesses connect with prospects, warm up email accounts, and manage campaigns at scale to maximize deliverability and response rates. The platform includes unlimited email account connections, a centralized inbox management system (Unibox), A/B testing capabilities, and unlimited AI-powered content generation without requiring external API keys. All premium features are included in every plan without additional costs or restrictions.

Average Rating: 5.0/5.0

Total Reviews: 2

How Do G2 Users Rate Reachkit?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)
  • Campaign Performance: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 10.0/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind Reachkit?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of Reachkit?

CircuPress

CircuPress is an email service provider built specifically for WordPress.

Average Rating: 5.0/5.0

Total Reviews: 1

Who Is the Company Behind CircuPress?

  • Seller: CircuPress
  • Year Founded: 2013
  • HQ Location: N/A
  • Twitter: @circupress
    977 Twitter followers
  • LinkedIn® Page: www.linkedin.com
    1 employees on LinkedIn®

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of CircuPress?

What Are G2 Users Discussing About CircuPress?

Cold Email Infrastructure

Puzzle Inbox is a cold email infrastructure provider that supplies ready-to-use email inboxes for outbound sales and cold outreach campaigns. The core offerings include: Google Workspace & Outlook 365 inboxes — pre-configured mailboxes optimized for cold email deliverability Done-for-you setup packages — fully managed inbox provisioning so clients don't have to handle domain purchasing, DNS configuration, or warmup themselves AI-powered outreach tools automation features to support cold email campaigns at scale

Average Rating: 4.5/5.0

Total Reviews: 1

Who Is the Company Behind Cold Email Infrastructure?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of Cold Email Infrastructure?

Coresender

Coresender is an email delivery service for transactional and marketing emails that can replace an in-house infrastructure. Easy SMTP service allows for a quick start, while a robust API gives full control over email processing and reporting. Transactional emails are delivered instantly, and marketing campaigns can be scaled to millions. * High deliverability rate * Email API * SMTP gateway * DKIM * SPF * Open tracking * Click tracking * Unsubscribe tracking

Average Rating: 5.0/5.0

Total Reviews: 1

Who Is the Company Behind Coresender?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Are Recent G2 Reviews of Coresender?

What Are G2 Users Discussing About Coresender?

Deliverite

Our self service email delivery system, Deliverite gives you full flexibility to manage and send your email campaigns in your own time. Powerful features and simple pricing makes Deliverite the perfect choice for your marketing team offering: Bespoke sending domain and click-tracking domain Control the speed of delivery on your email campaigns In depth reporting and analytics for each broadcast Ability to upload Global Email and Domain suppressions Unlimited Number of Data Lists in the Account Create Landing Page forms within the same account Automation and Sequences

Average Rating: 1.5/5.0

Total Reviews: 1

How Do G2 Users Rate Deliverite?

  • Has the product been a good partner in doing business?: 8.3/10 (Category avg: 9.1/10)
  • Campaign Performance: 8.3/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Content : 5.0/10 (Category avg: 8.8/10)
  • Brand Reputation: 5.0/10 (Category avg: 8.9/10)

Who Is the Company Behind Deliverite?

Who Uses This Product?

  • Company Size: 100% Small

What Do G2 Reviewers Say About Deliverite?

AI-generated summary from verified user reviews

Pros
  • Users appreciate the clear reports from Deliverite, making it easy to identify areas for campaign improvement.
  • Users find automation ease with Deliverite, enabling quick setup of lifecycle emails and effective campaign management.
  • Users find the ease of learning with Deliverite's intuitive tools allows quick setup and effective campaign management.
  • Users love the ease of use of Deliverite, finding setup and management quick and efficient for their email campaigns.
  • Users appreciate the efficiency of Deliverite, allowing quick setup of lifecycle emails and consistent campaign management.
Cons
  • Users find the email functionality lacking due to limited templates, sluggishness with large lists, and insufficient integrations.
  • Users find the limited features of Deliverite restrict their design options and integration capabilities significantly.
  • Users find the limited options in Deliverite's template library and integrations restrictive for their needs.
  • Users find the limited template options restricting, alongside a desire for enhanced UI performance and reporting flexibility.
  • Users find the list management capabilities lacking, citing limited templates, sluggish UI, and inflexible reporting options.
Yukta Rustagi
YR
Researched and written by Yukta Rustagi
Updated October 3, 2024