Unfortunately, I cannot identify anything positive about my experience with BrightHR. Whatever benefits the software may offer are completely overshadowed by my experience of its sales practices, lengthy contractual commitments and handling of complaints. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.
My biggest complaint about BrightHR is the way lengthy contractual commitments are presented during the sales process, followed by what I consider to be an extremely poor approach to resolving complaints.
As a small business owner, I was sold services primarily on the basis of affordable monthly payments. I do not recall being clearly informed that I was entering into a five-year payroll agreement, or that my HR agreement involved automatic two-year renewals with strict cancellation deadlines.
I subsequently discovered that BrightHR considered my business committed to payroll payments until January 2031, regardless of whether we actually used the service.
BrightHR has confirmed in writing that our payroll service never went live and that no payroll submissions were made to HMRC. Nevertheless, it continues to maintain that payments are contractually due.
What I find particularly unacceptable is the handling of my formal complaint. Rather than properly addressing my concerns about how these contracts were sold, BrightHR repeatedly focused on missed onboarding appointments, outstanding invoices and offers of account credits.
I have spent months attempting to obtain a substantive explanation and the original sales evidence. The dispute has now escalated to a formal Letter Before Action.
For a small business, the prospect of being tied into years of payments for services it no longer wants is deeply concerning.
In my experience, BrightHR's contractual arrangements and complaint-handling practices have completely undermined my confidence in the company.
I would strongly advise any prospective customer to scrutinise the full contract length, automatic renewal provisions, notice periods and early termination liabilities before signing anything.
**A monthly payment does not necessarily mean a monthly contract.** Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.
Hi, thank you for your feedback, just to confirm that we are in receipt of your most recent correspondence, and we will be liaising with you accordingly on this matter. Thanks, The BrightHR Team



