There are several things that I love about Big Cartel.
They make selling super easy! You don't have to worry about taxes because they remit them for you. You can link both Stripe and Paypal for easy payout. You can easily list and unlist items. Setting up your store from the design to obtaining your own domain is super simple.
The subscription is super affordable and you're not being price gouged to hell like you would on Shopify. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.
When it comes to things I dislike, it's a very short list.
I don't like that I can't fully customize my shop to my specific likings. While the templates are wonderful and chic and easy to use, I have some qualms with not being able to adjust to my liking the way I'd like.
Another thing I don't like is that there aren't better ways to pull reports on sales, inventory, etc. But I have a spreadsheet so it's not that big of deal breaker. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.