Best Payroll Services in 2025 | G2: Compare Reviews on 140+ Services

Introducing G2.ai, the future of software buying.Try now

What are payroll services?
How do payroll services work?
What do payroll services do?
Who uses payroll outsourcing services?
Payroll services cost
Payroll services benefits
Disadvantages of payroll services
What should you consider when choosing a payroll service provider?

Learn More About Payroll Services

A payroll service provider is a company that manages payroll administration for other businesses. These third-party organizations are responsible for calculating payroll and tax obligations for their client's employees to ensure accuracy and timely payments.

What are payroll services?

As an extension of a business's financial department, payroll services specialize in handling employee compensation. They support organizations by reducing the administrative burdens and risk of error or non-compliance. Outsourcing payroll processes allows internal resources to focus on the company’s core functions.

Some companies may take a direct approach by managing payroll themselves with the help of payroll software.

How do payroll services work?

Payroll outsourcing companies have an established system for managing their clients’ payroll processes. Typically, businesses are paired with dedicated account managers to address concerns. Some payroll service companies provide secure online portals that allow access to relevant information and payroll reports.

Here’s what a standard workflow for a payroll provider looks like:

Onboarding starts with setting up an account with the provider. You share details, like tax filing information and employee documentation, including names, addresses, social security numbers, and pay rates. During this phase, the payroll service establishment should provide you with the necessary training and implementation support.
Data integration results in more seamless collaboration by combining payroll services with your existing HR software. The automation eliminates the need for manual data entry through an online portal for each pay period.
Payroll processing occurs by calculating the gross pay for each employee. Your provider takes into account regular wages, overtime, and bonuses. They also factor in tax deductions, health insurance, and retirement contributions.
Tax deduction and filing require your provider to withhold applicable taxes from each employee's paycheck. The collective taxes are then electronically filed and paid to the relevant government agencies for your business.
Employee payments equal the amount that employees receive after tax deduction. Depending on the provider, it can be traditional paper checks, direct deposits, or pay card solutions.
Reporting and compliance information is detailed in the documentation that lists employee pay breakdowns, tax liabilities, and year-end summaries. Payroll service companies also make sure that all practices adhere to employment and tax laws to minimize the risk of compliance issues.

What do payroll services do?

Payroll companies perform a variety of tasks to verify that every aspect related to employee payment is handled with accuracy and compliance with the appropriate regulations. Their general responsibilities include:

Processing payroll. These firms calculate each employee's salary or hourly wages and apply necessary deductions like taxes, Medicare, or retirement contributions.
Handling taxes. They’re responsible for calculating and withholding the correct amount of taxes, filing payroll tax reports, and depositing tax withholdings to the appropriate tax agencies.
Distributing direct deposits and checks. Payroll companies initiate direct deposits or write checks for employees.
Confirming compliance. They stay updated on changes to legislation that may affect payroll management to make certain a client's payroll always adheres to labor laws and tax regulations.
Creating reports. Payroll providers deliver detailed reports to employees about payment and deductions. These reports are essential for accounting and auditing purposes; they’re often used at the executive level to monitor expenses.
Tracking employee benefits. Payroll service solutions record all employee benefits, including health insurance, retirement savings plans, and paid time off (PTO).
Filing year-end documentation. These firms manage year-end tax forms for employees to confirm they have all the documentation needed to file tax returns.
Serving as an employee interface. Corporate payroll services often bridge the gap between the employer and employees when it comes to answering inquiries and resolving remuneration issues.

Who uses payroll outsourcing services?

Payroll service providers accommodate needs across different industries and company sizes. Any business that needs to manage employee compensation or contractor payments may find value in payroll outsourcing services.

Human resources departments: Outsourcing the time-consuming payroll process allows HR departments to focus on core functions like recruitment, employee relations, and training. Payroll service providers are also generally more knowledgeable about current tax laws and regulations than in-house HR personnel.
Accountants: Payroll providers have robust internal controls that strengthen the overall financial management of an organization. The time saved by handing over payroll to a third party lets accountants dedicate more time to providing strategic financial insights. If not completely outsourced, accountants also communicate and collaborate with payroll providers to do their work.
Small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs): Hiring, training, and managing payroll in-house strain the limited resources that SMBs have. Outsourcing payroll services guarantees accuracy, saves time, and avoids potential penalties associated with errors and non-compliance.
Rapidly scaling businesses: Outsourcing means you can adjust payroll processes as needed and, in turn, avoid the need for constant upgrades or additional staff. Payroll companies quickly adapt to accommodate growth in employee numbers and ensure a smooth process during rapid expansion.
Startups: Using payroll service providers can liberate startups to dedicate their resources to essential business functions like product development, marketing, or customer acquisition.

Payroll services cost

The cost of payroll outsourcing services varies depending on the number of employees, the frequency and complexity of payroll, and factors like expense management and benefits administration.

Here’s what different pricing models look like for payroll service solutions:

Per employee per month (PEPM) is a standard pricing model where businesses are charged a base monthly fee plus an additional fee for each employee. This model is straightforward and scalable, making it popular among businesses of all sizes.
Flat monthly fees include a specific set of services for an unlimited number of employees. This can be economical for businesses with a larger workforce but might include additional charges for extra services.
Pay-per-run means businesses pay each time they process a payroll. This can be cost-effective for companies with stable employees but less frequent payroll cycles. However, costs can add up for businesses running multiple monthly payrolls.
Tiered pricing offers different service packages according to price. Higher tiers may consist of customizable and advanced features such as HR support, tax filing assistance, and access to employee benefits management. Businesses can choose a tier that best fits their needs and budget.
Custom pricing may be a requirement for enterprises or businesses with complex payroll needs. In these cases, the payroll service provider tailors a pricing package based on the services and level of support the company’s specification.
Additional fees like year-end tax form preparation, account setup, or software integration may be incurred.

Return on investment (ROI) for payroll outsourcing services

Payroll outsourcing offers a substantial ROI. However, you have to consider the factors below to determine if payroll outsourcing is worthwhile.

Compliance and risk management: Avoiding penalties for tax and regulatory non-compliance isn’t up for negotiation. Effective corporate payroll services reduce the risk of costly legal and financial penalties, which improves ROI.
Time savings: The amount of time saved by outsourcing payroll tasks, which can then be redirected toward integral business activities, directly contributes to a higher ROI.
Scalability: Find a provider that can adapt to your company's growth without significant additional costs. This ensures that your ROI remains positive as you expand.
Accuracy and reliability: Minimizing errors in payroll processing improves ROI by reducing the need for corrections and the potential for employee dissatisfaction. High accuracy and reliability also result in cost savings and enhanced company reputation.
Employee satisfaction: Self-service portals for pay stubs and tax information make staying informed less stressful for employees, indirectly contributing to productivity and ROI.
Integration capabilities: Integrating existing HR and accounting systems seamlessly leads to more efficient operations and better data management.
Data security: Strong data security measures prevent potential breaches, avoid costs associated with data theft, and safeguard the integrity of the payroll system.

Payroll services benefits

The payroll process can be complex and time-consuming, especially for growing businesses that lack dedicated HR resources. The decision to outsource significantly affects the efficiency and success of a company.

Time savings: Payroll outsourcing services automate payroll runs so companies save time and dedicate staff hours to essential projects.
Cost efficiency: Outsourcing for mid-size and small business owners is more manageable than hiring an entire team to run payroll.
Legal compliance: Corporate payroll services are required to take on risk and keep up with local, state, federal, and international laws. They also assume financial accountability if they file late or incorrectly. They absorb the penalties.
Accessing multiple services: Organizations may need additional features that payroll companies offer, like tracking time and attendance, direct deposit, tax filing, health benefits management, and HR services. They provide an all-in-one solution for your business.
Reliability: Professional payroll services are reliable and consistent with payment processing, which helps keep employees satisfied.
Scalability: As a business grows, payroll services can quickly scale to accommodate new employees, handle tax filings in different states, and manage complexities without the need for you to make a significant investment in new software or staff training.
Employee access to information: Many payroll processing companies offer portals where workers can view their pay stubs, track their benefits, and manage their tax withholdings to foster transparency and engagement.
Peace of mind: Knowing that experts are managing your payroll and tax processes gives business owners like you peace of mind, allowing you to focus on growing your business with fewer things to worry about.

Disadvantages of payroll services

Payroll services, while offering numerous benefits, also face several challenges.

Compliance: Payroll must adhere to the constantly changing local, state, and federal tax laws and regulations. This requires staying up to date with legislation changes, which can be particularly challenging for payroll businesses that operate in multiple jurisdictions or countries.
Data security: Payroll services handle sensitive employee information, such as social security numbers and bank details, making them prime targets for cyberattacks. Ensuring robust security measures to protect this data is crucial.
Integration with other systems: Payroll firms must communicate seamlessly with HR and accounting software. This can involve complex technical configurations to confirm accurate data flow and prevent errors.
Scalability: As businesses grow and their payroll needs become more complex, payroll services must adapt quickly and efficiently to these changes.

What should you consider when choosing a payroll service provider?

Payroll outsourcing enhances business productivity by freeing up valuable time. However, choosing the right payroll service solution requires careful consideration.

Identify your needs: Clearly outline what you need from an online payroll service, including basic payroll processing, tax filing, benefits administration, and compliance management.
Consider your budget: Determine how much you're willing to spend on payroll services and look for options that offer the features you need within your budget.
Evaluate features and services: Compare the features offered by different payroll companies, such as direct deposit, tax services, employee self-service portals, time tracking, and integration capabilities with your existing HR tools.
Check compliance capabilities: Make sure the payroll service knows federal, state, and local tax laws to keep your business compliant and avoid penalties.
Assess scalability: Choose a payroll service that can scale with your business as it grows, both in terms of the number of employees and geographic expansion.
Look for security measures: Given the sensitivity of payroll data, opt for a service with comprehensive security protocols to protect your employees' information.
Read reviews and testimonials: Look for feedback from current and past customers to gauge the service's reliability, customer support, and ease of use.
Consider customer support: Make certain that the payroll service provides timely and helpful customer support. Find out if they offer support through multiple channels (phone, email, chat) and their availability (24/7, business hours only).
Request a demo: Before deciding, get a demo or a free trial for hands-on experience with the service.
Understand the contract: Review the contract or service agreement carefully by paying close attention to the terms, conditions, hidden fees, and the cancellation policy.