Reduce your software costs by 18% overnight

Compare Servant Keeper and Shelby Financials

See this
side-by-side comparison of Servant Keeper vs. Shelby Financials
based on preference data from user reviews. Servant Keeper rates 3.9/5 stars with 18 reviews. By contrast, Shelby Financials rates 3.5/5 stars with 7 reviews. Each product's score is calculated with real-time data from verified user reviews, to help you make the best choice between these two options, and decide which one is best for your business needs.
Add Product
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
(18)
3.9 out of 5
Servant Keeper
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
(7)
3.5 out of 5
Shelby Financials
Star Rating
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
Market Segments
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
Small-Business (94.4% of reviews)
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
Small-Business (80.0% of reviews)
Entry Level Price
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
$250
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
No pricing information available
Categories
Shared Categories
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
Servant Keeper and Shelby Financials are categorized as Church Management
Unique Categories
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper has no unique categories
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials is categorized as Nonprofit Accounting
Pricing
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper Pricing
Small Church
$250
Standard
$499one time initial license fee
Seat License
$50per additional computer
Free Trial Unavailable
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials Pricing
Free Trial Unavailable
Ratings
Meets Requirements
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
8.2
Responses: 14
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
8.0
Responses: 5
Ease of Use
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
7.6
Responses: 15
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
6.7
Responses: 5
Ease of Setup
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
7.5
Responses: 10
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
Not enough data available
Ease of Admin
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
8.5
Responses: 10
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
Not enough data available
Quality of Support
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
7.3
Responses: 15
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
Not enough data available
Ease of Doing Business With
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
8.8
Responses: 10
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
Not enough data available
Product Direction (% positive)
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
7.7
Responses: 15
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
7.7
Responses: 5
Reviewers' Company Size
Reviewers of both Servant Keeper and Shelby Financials were most often representing companies in the Small-Business segment.
Small-Business
(50 or fewer emp.)
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
94.4%
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
80.0%
Mid-Market
(51-1000 emp.)
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
0%
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
0%
Enterprise
(> 1000 emp.)
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper
5.6%
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials
20.0%
Reviewers' Industry
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper Industry
Religious Institutions
77.8%
Non-Profit Organization Management
11.1%
Performing Arts
5.6%
Higher Education
5.6%
Other
0.0%
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials Industry
Religious Institutions
60.0%
Non-Profit Organization Management
20.0%
Higher Education
20.0%
Other
0.0%
Reviews
Most Helpful Favorable Review
Servant Keeper
Rosa Y.
Administrator in Religious Institutions

I have been using Servant Keeper for over 10 years now. I like it that it keeps all my information up to date. It is easy to use. I use the desktop software. It is easy to transfer files using CSV spreadsheets. I can send statements by mail or email. I...

Shelby Financials
GR
User in Religious Institutions

Shelby has everything we need for online giving from our community members.

Most Helpful Critical Review
Servant Keeper
Brett N.
User in Religious Institutions

It is not very intuitive, and it does not allow all of the categorization options we desire.

Shelby Financials
Sean T.
User in Higher Education

Awkward / intuitive user interface.. Searching for members and editing information was not as simple as interfaces in other software.

Discussions
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper Discussions
Monty the Mongoose crying
Servant Keeper has no discussions with answers
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials Discussions
Monty the Mongoose crying
Shelby Financials has no discussions with answers
Screenshots
Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper Screenshots
No screenshots provided
Shelby Financials
Shelby Financials Screenshots
Request More InformationRequest More InformationRequest More InformationRequest More Information
Need help?
I can help.
Kate
Learning about Business Software?
Ask the community