Reduce your software costs by 18% overnight

Compare ProPay and Shift4 Payments

See this
side-by-side comparison of ProPay vs. Shift4 Payments
based on preference data from user reviews. ProPay rates 3.8/5 stars with 5 reviews. By contrast, Shift4 Payments rates 4.0/5 stars with 14 reviews. Each product's score is calculated with real-time data from verified user reviews, to help you make the best choice between these two options, and decide which one is best for your business needs.
Add Product
ProPay
ProPay
(5)
3.8 out of 5
ProPay
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
(14)
4.0 out of 5
Shift4 Payments
Star Rating
ProPay
ProPay
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Market Segments
ProPay
ProPay
Small-Business (60.0% of reviews)
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Mid-Market (71.4% of reviews)
Entry Level Price
ProPay
ProPay
No pricing information available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
No pricing information available
Categories
Shared Categories
ProPay
ProPay
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
ProPay and Shift4 Payments are categorized as Payment Processing
Unique Categories
ProPay
ProPay is categorized as Enterprise Payment
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments is categorized as Payment Gateways
Pricing
ProPay
ProPay Pricing
Free Trial Unavailable
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments Pricing
Free Trial Unavailable
Ratings
Meets Requirements
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
7.2
Responses: 9
Ease of Use
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
7.4
Responses: 9
Ease of Setup
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Ease of Admin
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Quality of Support
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
7.0
Responses: 9
Ease of Doing Business With
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Product Direction (% positive)
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
6.8
Responses: 11
Features
Payment Processing
Encryption
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Credit Card Processing
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Mobile Payments
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Digital Wallet Integration
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Administration
Reporting & Analytics
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
E-commerce Integration
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Processing Fees
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
POS Integration
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Omnichannel
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Levels 1 & 2
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Level 3
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Payment Options
Multi-Currency
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Online payment portal
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Security
POS Verification
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Platform
Accounting integration
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
E-commerce Integration
ProPay
ProPay
Not enough data available
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
Not enough data available
Reviewers' Company Size
Reviewers of ProPay were most often representing companies in the Small-Business segment, while reviewers for Shift4 Payments were more commonly in the Mid-Market segment.
Small-Business
(50 or fewer emp.)
ProPay
ProPay
60.0%
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
28.6%
Mid-Market
(51-1000 emp.)
ProPay
ProPay
0%
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
71.4%
Enterprise
(> 1000 emp.)
ProPay
ProPay
40.0%
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments
0%
Reviewers' Industry
ProPay
ProPay Industry
Cosmetics
60.0%
Retail
20.0%
Consumer Goods
20.0%
Other
0.0%
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments Industry
Non-Profit Organization Management
14.3%
Information Technology and Services
14.3%
Hospitality
14.3%
Marketing and Advertising
7.1%
Health, Wellness and Fitness
7.1%
Other
42.9%
Reviews
Most Helpful Favorable Review
ProPay
Cheryl G.
User in Consumer Goods

It is convenient because it is compatible with my Mary Kay web page. It integrates so my customers can use credit cares on my website.

Shift4 Payments
Jennifer R.
Administrator in Construction

Our company has been using Shift4 Payments for almost 3 years and have been happy with it being so user friendly and we also appreciate that the website interface is good.

Most Helpful Critical Review
ProPay
Monica F.
User in Cosmetics

What I disliked the most was the fee associated with any transaction. I would much rather go to a bank to deposit cash and checks than be charged the fees.

Shift4 Payments
GP
User in Education Management

I can’t manually adjust my timesheet, it’s very frustrating

Discussions
ProPay
ProPay Discussions
Monty the Mongoose crying
ProPay has no discussions with answers
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments Discussions
Monty the Mongoose crying
Shift4 Payments has no discussions with answers
Screenshots
ProPay
ProPay Screenshots
No screenshots provided
Shift4 Payments
Shift4 Payments Screenshots
No screenshots provided
Request More InformationRequest More InformationRequest More InformationRequest More Information
Need help?
I can help.
Kate
Learning about Business Software?
Ask the community