Link copied to clipboard

# MXToolbox vs Red Sift OnDMARC Comparison - What are their main differences?

Share
[
Export
](/compare/mxtoolbox/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/export.csv)

MXToolboxRed Sift OnDMARC[+ Add Product](#)

Reviews

**MXToolbox** [

4.1/5(29)

](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews#reviews)

**Red Sift OnDMARC** [

4.8/5(107)

](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews#reviews)

Pricing

**MXToolbox**
Free Trial

**Starting at $129.00** Per Month · MxToolbox Delivery Center

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
Free Trial

**Starting at $12.00** Per Month · Express

**Pricing Insights**
from reviews

Time to Implement

**MXToolbox**
Not enough reviews yet

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
2 months

Based on 7 responses

Return on Investment

**MXToolbox**
Not enough reviews yet

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
3 months

Based on 7 responses

Perceived Cost

**MXToolbox**
$$$$$

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
$$$$$

Average Discount

**MXToolbox**
Not enough reviews yet

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
8%

Pros & Cons

**MXToolbox**
[
Data Analysis (2)
](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1563369&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
DMARC Management (2)
](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1563175&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
Costly Services (1)
](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=2002487&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
Email Functionality (1)
](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1563233&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
[
Customer Support (48)
](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1088984&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
Ease of Use (42)
](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1087695&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
Complexity (5)
](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1090145&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
Dashboard Issues (5)
](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1088492&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)

Integrations

**MXToolbox**
Not enough data

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
[

 ![Product Avatar Image](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/large_detail/large_detail_ebfae2a9075850f9fa094c23484ef258/microsoft-entra-id.jpg "Product Avatar Image")

Microsoft Entra ID

](https://www.g2.com/products/microsoft-entra-id/reviews)[
View all
](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/integrations)

Screenshots

**MXToolbox**
 ![MXToolbox screenshot](https://images.g2crowd.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=600,height=600,fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,/https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/attachment/file/184630/manage-domains_1_.jpg)

**Red Sift OnDMARC**
 ![Red Sift OnDMARC screenshot](https://images.g2crowd.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=600,height=600,fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,/https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/attachment/file/153572/OnDMARC-Enforcement-_1_.png)

Ratings

Meets Requirements

**MXToolbox**

9.0

9.023

**Red Sift OnDMARC**

9.7

9.788

Ease of Use

**MXToolbox**

9.2

9.224

**Red Sift OnDMARC**

9.4

9.491

Ease of Setup

**MXToolbox**

9.5

9.519

**Red Sift OnDMARC**

9.4

9.489

Ease of Admin

**MXToolbox**

9.3

9.314

**Red Sift OnDMARC**

9.3

9.382

Quality of Support

**MXToolbox**

7.8

7.815

**Red Sift OnDMARC**

9.8

9.888

Has the product been a good partner in doing business?

**MXToolbox**

8.2

8.212

**Red Sift OnDMARC**

9.7

9.780

Product Direction (% positive)

**MXToolbox**

8.5

8.524

**Red Sift OnDMARC**

9.6

9.686

Features

DMARC[Hide 11 FeaturesShow 11 Features](javascript:void(0);)

8.9

8

9.0

83

Diagnostics

Account Overview

9.2

8

9.4(won by 0.2)

78

DMARC Alignment

9.8(won by 0.2)

8

9.6

80

Analytics

9.0

8

9.1(won by 0.1)

78

Compliance

Policy Configuration

8.8

8

9.3(won by 0.5)

66

 (There is a greater than 0.5 difference between this product's rating and its competitors)

Alerts

8.3

8

8.8(won by 0.5)

77

 (There is a greater than 0.5 difference between this product's rating and its competitors)

Outbound Emails

8.8

8

9.4(won by 0.6)

75

 (There is a greater than 0.5 difference between this product's rating and its competitors)

Inbound Emails

Feature Not Available

Feature Not Available

Protection

Threat Identifications

8.5

8

8.6(won by 0.1)

77

Threat Interception

Feature Not Available

8.7(won by default)

72

Integrations

Feature Not Available

7.9(won by default)

58

Threat Removal

Feature Not Available

Feature Not Available

Email Deliverability[Hide 18 FeaturesShow 18 Features](javascript:void(0);)

8.3

8

Not enough data

Diagnosis

IP Address 

9.0(won by default)

8

Not enough data

Domains

9.4(won by default)

8

Not enough data

Content 

7.6(won by default)

7

Not enough data

Policy Compliance

8.1(won by default)

7

Not enough data

Tracking

Processing Time

8.8(won by default)

7

Not enough data

Placement 

8.1(won by default)

6

Not enough data

Alerts

6.4(won by default)

6

Not enough data

Open Rate

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Time to Open

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Reporting

Domain Reputation

9.2(won by default)

6

Not enough data

Brand Reputation

8.3(won by default)

6

Not enough data

Blacklist and Whitelist

8.3(won by default)

6

Not enough data

Campaign Performance

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Agentic AI - Email Deliverability

Autonomous Task Execution

Not enough data

Not enough data

Cross-system Integration

Not enough data

Not enough data

Adaptive Learning

Not enough data

Not enough data

Proactive Assistance

Not enough data

Not enough data

Decision Making

Not enough data

Not enough data

DNS Security Solutions[Hide 14 FeaturesShow 14 Features](javascript:void(0);)

10.0

5

Not enough data

Protection

Quarantine

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Continuous Monitoring

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Off-Network Protection

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Guest Network Protection

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

BYOD Protection

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Native DNS over HTTPS (DoH)

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Functionality

DNS Lookups

10.0(won by default)

5

Not enough data

Threat Intelligence

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Advanced Traffic Filtering

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Administration

Whitelisting

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Policy Enforcement

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Incident Reports

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Domain Categorization

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Multi-Network Management

Feature Not Available

Not enough data

Show 2 feature categories with incomplete data

Other IT Infrastructure[Hide 52 FeaturesShow 52 Features](javascript:void(0);)

Not enough data

Not enough data

Additional Functionality

Role-Based Permissions

Not enough data

Not enough data

Configurable Workflow

Not enough data

Not enough data

Access Controls/Permissions

Not enough data

Not enough data

Assignment Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Help Desk Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Projections

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Reports

Not enough data

Not enough data

Issue Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Fields

Not enough data

Not enough data

Reporting & Statistics

Not enough data

Not enough data

API

Not enough data

Not enough data

Alerts/Notifications

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Forms

Not enough data

Not enough data

Recurring Issues

Not enough data

Not enough data

Widgets

Not enough data

Not enough data

Workflow Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Prioritization

Not enough data

Not enough data

Third-Party Integrations

Not enough data

Not enough data

Commenting/Notes

Not enough data

Not enough data

Issue Auditing

Not enough data

Not enough data

AI Copilot

Not enough data

Not enough data

Task Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Updates

Not enough data

Not enough data

Generative AI

Not enough data

Not enough data

Collaboration Tools

Not enough data

Not enough data

Dashboard

Not enough data

Not enough data

Self Service Portal

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Notifications

Not enough data

Not enough data

Support Ticket Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Drag & Drop

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Templates

Not enough data

Not enough data

Project Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Issue Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Dashboard

Not enough data

Not enough data

Tagging

Not enough data

Not enough data

Monitoring

Not enough data

Not enough data

Service Level Agreement (SLA) Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Branding

Not enough data

Not enough data

Multi-Channel Communication

Not enough data

Not enough data

Support Ticket Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Task Progress Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Issue Scheduling

Not enough data

Not enough data

Ticket Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Chat/Messaging

Not enough data

Not enough data

Rules-Based Workflow

Not enough data

Not enough data

Alerts/Escalation

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Reporting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Knowledge Base Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Surveys & Feedback

Not enough data

Not enough data

SSL Security

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Email Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Network Security[Hide 40 FeaturesShow 40 Features](javascript:void(0);)

Not enough data

Not enough data

Additional Functionality

Penetration Testing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Alerts/Notifications

Not enough data

Not enough data

Audit Trail

Not enough data

Not enough data

Anti Virus

Not enough data

Not enough data

Vulnerability Scanning

Not enough data

Not enough data

Remote Monitoring & Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

VPN

Not enough data

Not enough data

Behavior Analytics

Not enough data

Not enough data

Reporting/Analytics

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Notifications

Not enough data

Not enough data

Access Controls/Permissions

Not enough data

Not enough data

SSL Security

Not enough data

Not enough data

Patch Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Event Logs

Not enough data

Not enough data

Anomaly/Malware Detection

Not enough data

Not enough data

DNS Leak Protection

Not enough data

Not enough data

Third-Party Integrations

Not enough data

Not enough data

Server Monitoring

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Monitoring

Not enough data

Not enough data

Compliance Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Network Provisioning

Not enough data

Not enough data

API

Not enough data

Not enough data

Email Alerts

Not enough data

Not enough data

Security Auditing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Intrusion Detection System

Not enough data

Not enough data

Data Visualization

Not enough data

Not enough data

Two-Factor Authentication

Not enough data

Not enough data

Generative AI

Not enough data

Not enough data

Firewalls

Not enough data

Not enough data

AI Copilot

Not enough data

Not enough data

Anti Spam

Not enough data

Not enough data

Threat Response

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Monitoring

Not enough data

Not enough data

Risk Alerts

Not enough data

Not enough data

Data Loss Prevention

Not enough data

Not enough data

Single Sign On

Not enough data

Not enough data

Intrusion Prevention System

Not enough data

Not enough data

Secure Login

Not enough data

Not enough data

Policy Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Dashboard

Not enough data

Not enough data

User Insights

Reviewers' Company Size

[![MXToolbox](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/3871fdf6162eb6bdcd9822372347a5d4/mxtoolbox.svg "MXToolbox")](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews)

MXToolbox

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)

53.6%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)

32.1%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)

14.3%

[![Red Sift OnDMARC](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/31f87a6f7471f2b058999e683a8f52ec/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc.svg "Red Sift OnDMARC")](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews)

Red Sift OnDMARC

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)

11.9%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)

58.4%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)

29.7%

Small-Business

(50 or fewer emp.)

53.6%

11.9%

Mid-Market

(51-1000 emp.)

32.1%

58.4%

Enterprise

(\> 1000 emp.)

14.3%

29.7%

Reviewers' Industry

[![MXToolbox](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/3871fdf6162eb6bdcd9822372347a5d4/mxtoolbox.svg "MXToolbox")](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews)
MXToolbox

Information Technology and Services

25.0%

Internet

14.3%

Computer & Network Security

10.7%

Computer Software

7.1%

Textiles

3.6%

Other

39.3%

[![Red Sift OnDMARC](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/31f87a6f7471f2b058999e683a8f52ec/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc.svg "Red Sift OnDMARC")](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews)
Red Sift OnDMARC

Financial Services

8.1%

Retail

8.1%

Non-Profit Organization Management

6.1%

Legal Services

5.1%

Computer & Network Security

4.0%

Other

68.7%

FAQs

## MXToolbox vs Red Sift OnDMARC FAQs

Generated using AI

Last updated: August 16, 2026

### What is the difference between MXToolbox vs Red Sift OnDMARC?

Red Sift OnDMARC stands out from MXToolbox with a higher G2 rating, superior support, and more advanced DMARC management features.

| [MXToolbox](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews) | [Red Sift OnDMARC](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews) |
| --- | --- |
| 4.1/5 (29 reviews) | 4.8/5 (107 reviews) |
| — | Mid-Market |
| 9.5 | 9.4 |
| 7.8 | 9.8 |
| Data Analysis | Customer Support |

### How do the pricing models of MXToolbox and Red Sift OnDMARC compare?

Red Sift OnDMARC is rated higher for value, with reviewers expressing greater satisfaction with its pricing compared to MXToolbox.

- **MXToolbox:** In recent reviews, some reviewers mention that the free tier is useful but deeper features require paid plans, and there are concerns about costly services.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC:** Reviewers highlight great value for the features provided, with positive sentiment around the investment and ongoing feature development.
- **Switching Reason:** Recent reviewers have switched from Valimail to Red Sift OnDMARC for better features and value.

### What are the best alternatives to MXToolbox and Red Sift OnDMARC?

The top 3 alternatives to MXToolbox and Red Sift OnDMARC are EasyDMARC, Valimail, and DMARC Report.

| Product | G2 Rating (reviews) | Largest Segment | Pricing Insight | Top Reviewer-Cited Strength |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [MXToolbox](https://www.g2.com/products/mxtoolbox/reviews) | 4.1/5 (29 reviews) | — | Free tier praised, but paid features seen as costly | Data Analysis |
| [Red Sift OnDMARC](https://www.g2.com/products/red-sift-red-sift-ondmarc/reviews) | 4.8/5 (107 reviews) | Mid-Market | Great value for features, ongoing development | Customer Support |
| [EasyDMARC](https://www.g2.com/products/easydmarc/reviews) | 4.7/5 (258 reviews) | Small-Business | — | — |
| [Valimail](https://www.g2.com/products/valimail/reviews) | 4.5/5 (656 reviews) | Small-Business | — | — |
| [DMARC Report](https://www.g2.com/products/dmarc-report/reviews) | 4.8/5 (473 reviews) | Small-Business | — | — |

### Which DMARC features should I prioritize when comparing MXToolbox and Red Sift OnDMARC?

Buyers should prioritize DMARC management, customer support, integrations, dashboard usability, and reporting when comparing MXToolbox and Red Sift OnDMARC.

- **DMARC Management:** MXToolbox (2 all-time mentions), Red Sift OnDMARC (27 all-time mentions)
- **Customer Support:** MXToolbox (no recent theme), Red Sift OnDMARC (51 all-time mentions)
- **Integrations:** MXToolbox (1 all-time mention), Red Sift OnDMARC (feature present, integrations supported)
- **Dashboard Usability:** MXToolbox (no recent theme), Red Sift OnDMARC (12 all-time mentions)
- **Reporting:** MXToolbox (no recent theme), Red Sift OnDMARC (8 all-time mentions)

### What are the pros and cons of MXToolbox vs Red Sift OnDMARC?

Red Sift OnDMARC's headline strength is customer support, while MXToolbox is recognized for data analysis capabilities.

- **MXToolbox strengths:** Data analysis, DMARC management, and easy integrations are cited in recent reviews.
- **MXToolbox trade-offs:** Reviewers mention costly services and concerns about paid feature value.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC strengths:** Customer support (51 all-time mentions), ease of use (45), easy setup (30), DMARC management (27), and dashboard usability (12) are consistently praised.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC trade-offs:** Some reviewers note a learning curve for new users and a desire for more granular pricing tiers for smaller sender volumes.

### Is MXToolbox or Red Sift OnDMARC better for small businesses?

EasyDMARC, Valimail, and DMARC Report are all rated higher for small-business fit than MXToolbox or Red Sift OnDMARC, but among the two, Red Sift OnDMARC is more frequently cited by mid-market reviewers.

- **MXToolbox:** No dominant small-business segment share is reported, and recent reviews do not highlight small-business-specific sentiment.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC:** Largest reviewer segment is Mid-Market, with reviewers praising its value and support for managing multiple domains, but not specifically highlighting small-business fit.

### Which DMARC platform has better integrations?

Red Sift OnDMARC is favored for integrations, as it is the only product with integrations cited in both features and reviews.

- **MXToolbox:** Easy integrations are mentioned in recent reviews, but only one all-time mention is recorded.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC:** Integrations are a supported feature and are highlighted in recent reviews, with specific mentions of Microsoft 365 and SAML integration.

### How do MXToolbox and Red Sift OnDMARC compare on customer support?

Red Sift OnDMARC outperforms MXToolbox on Quality of Support by a material margin of 2.0 points (9.8 vs 7.8).

- **MXToolbox:** Reviewers describe support as generally responsive, but some cite negative experiences with contract handling and refund processes.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC:** Reviewers consistently praise customer support, with 51 all-time mentions, highlighting proactive, knowledgeable, and highly responsive service.

### Which is easier to implement, MXToolbox or Red Sift OnDMARC?

MXToolbox and Red Sift OnDMARC are rated nearly identically on Ease of Setup (9.5 vs 9.4), indicating parity for implementation simplicity.

- **MXToolbox:** Reviewers consistently rate setup as easy, with multiple mentions of straightforward implementation and helpful setup wizards.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC:** Reviewers highlight easy onboarding, guided setup, and step-by-step assistance, with 30 all-time mentions of easy setup and 24 for implementation ease.

### Which product has better Domains?

Red Sift OnDMARC is the stronger product for Domains, as it is more frequently cited for domain management and related features.

- **MXToolbox:** Domains are mentioned in the context of DNS and MX record lookups, with reviewers noting its utility for domain reputation and deliverability checks.
- **Red Sift OnDMARC:** Domains are a core focus, with reviewers citing management of hundreds of domains, dynamic SPF/DKIM/DMARC records, and 27 all-time mentions for DMARC management and 12 for dashboard usability related to domains.

Alternatives

**MXToolbox Alternatives**

 ![EasyDMARC](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/1de8f37430beae27cda84fca590230f1/easydmarc.svg "EasyDMARC")

[
EasyDMARC
](/products/easydmarc/reviews)

 ![Valimail](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/3afbe436dad9efae1261e590d884c536/valimail.svg "Valimail")

[
Valimail
](/products/valimail/reviews)

 ![DMARC Report](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/b79eab1b78f05e2111b5c672d4f9be66/dmarc-report.svg "DMARC Report")

[
DMARC Report
](/products/dmarc-report/reviews)

 ![Twilio SendGrid Email API](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/11065b0c84d6d0a6c0a8e8ade2b9467e/twilio-sendgrid-email-api.svg "Twilio SendGrid Email API")

[
Twilio SendGrid Email API
](/products/twilio-sendgrid-email-api/reviews)

**Red Sift OnDMARC Alternatives**

 ![EasyDMARC](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/1de8f37430beae27cda84fca590230f1/easydmarc.svg "EasyDMARC")

[
EasyDMARC
](/products/easydmarc/reviews)

 ![Valimail](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/3afbe436dad9efae1261e590d884c536/valimail.svg "Valimail")

[
Valimail
](/products/valimail/reviews)

 ![PowerDMARC](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/d0e6f1a407b661a0ad6753df25e02d9d/powerdmarc.svg "PowerDMARC")

[
PowerDMARC
](/products/powerdmarc/reviews)

 ![DMARC Report](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/b79eab1b78f05e2111b5c672d4f9be66/dmarc-report.svg "DMARC Report")

[
DMARC Report
](/products/dmarc-report/reviews)