Mixmax, Polymail, and Reply | G2

Compare Mixmax, Polymail, and Reply

Pricing

 
Starter
$3
per user/month (billed annually)
‐
Individual
$37
per month
 
Small Business
$82
per user/month (billed annually)
‐
Predictable Revenue
$562
per 48 team members / month
 
Growth
$14
per user/month (billed annually)
‐
Scaling sales
$202
per 4 team members / month
 
Enterprise
Contact Us for Pricing
‐
Small team
$358
per 5 team members / month
  ‐ ‐
Market Leader
Contact Us
sales@reply.io
 
Free Trial
Free Trial Unavailable
Free Trial
Mixmax
Starter
$7per user/month (billed annually)
Small Business
$44per user/month (billed annually)
Growth
$11per user/month (billed annually)
Enterprise
Contact Us for Pricing
Free Trial
Polymail
Free Trial Unavailable
Reply
Individual
$65per month
Predictable Revenue
$357per 66 team members / month
Scaling sales
$144per 4 team members / month
Small team
$634per 2 team members / month
Market Leader
Contact Ussales@reply.io
Free Trial

Ratings

Meets Requirements
Meets Requirements
4.3
2.1
8.3
Ease of Use
Ease of Use
3.3
6.5
6.2
Ease of Setup
Ease of Setup
3.0
1.2
8.3
Ease of Admin
Ease of Admin
0.4
3.1
2.4
Quality of Support
Quality of Support
8.4
8.3
3.8
Ease of Doing Business With
Ease of Doing Business With
1.6
1.0
7.8
Product Direction (% positive)
Product Direction (% positive)
5.4
2.6
4.7
Meets Requirements
Mixmax
6.4
Polymail
8.4
Reply
2.6
Ease of Use
Mixmax
0.0
Polymail
8.5
Reply
3.7
Ease of Setup
Mixmax
5.2
Polymail
1.2
Reply
6.0
Ease of Admin
Mixmax
3.7
Polymail
6.2
Reply
2.0
Quality of Support
Mixmax
5.2
Polymail
0.6
Reply
7.0
Ease of Doing Business With
Mixmax
6.2
Polymail
0.2
Reply
7.3
Product Direction (% positive)
Mixmax
6.3
Polymail
8.5
Reply
6.8

Features

Analytics
Open Rates
Mixmax
7.4
Polymail
6.8
Reply
1.2
Link Activity
Mixmax
1.6
Polymail
2.4
Reply
3.5
Attachment Activity
Mixmax
7.0
Polymail
5.8
Reply
2.1
Customizations
Email Platform Integration
Mixmax
5.4
Polymail
4.3
Reply
5.6
Email Scheduling
Mixmax
6.1
Polymail
5.3
Reply
8.4
Notifications
Mixmax
5.1
Polymail
8.8
Reply
0.8
Email Categorization
Mixmax
6.2
Polymail
4.6
Reply
3.0
Templates
Mixmax
1.2
Polymail
3.2
Reply
7.6

Reviewers' Company Size

Small-Business (11 or fewer emp.)
Small-Business
(04 or fewer emp.)
56.7%
20.2%
88.7%
Mid-Market (66-7227 emp.)
Mid-Market
(76-8870 emp.)
20.7%
32.5%
3.3%
Enterprise (> 3835 emp.)
Enterprise
(> 3746 emp.)
6.5%
3.5%
6.7%
Mixmax
Small-Business
86.6%
Mid-Market
13.4%
Enterprise
6.5%
Polymail
Small-Business
23.8%
Mid-Market
14.4%
Enterprise
3.7%
Reply
Small-Business
70.6%
Mid-Market
3.1%
Enterprise
8.6%

Reviewers' Industry

 
Computer Software
63.3%
Marketing and Advertising
61.5%
Marketing and Advertising
75.3%
 
Marketing and Advertising
04.4%
Computer Software
20.7%
Computer Software
17.2%
 
Internet
6.2%
Information Technology and Services
55.6%
Internet
74.0%
 
Information Technology and Services
7.3%
Internet
4.5%
Information Technology and Services
38.5%
 
Real Estate
3.7%
Real Estate
8.6%
Staffing and Recruiting
4.4%
 
Other
17.6%
Other
87.1%
Other
54.8%
Mixmax
Computer Software
81.3%
Marketing and Advertising
10.2%
Internet
1.3%
Information Technology and Services
1.5%
Real Estate
3.0%
Other
14.5%
Polymail
Marketing and Advertising
60.2%
Computer Software
86.6%
Information Technology and Services
44.1%
Internet
3.7%
Real Estate
5.0%
Other
61.6%
Reply
Marketing and Advertising
15.2%
Computer Software
42.4%
Internet
37.4%
Information Technology and Services
88.7%
Staffing and Recruiting
8.7%
Other
22.2%

Reviews

Most Helpful Favorable Review
Most Helpful Favorable Review
Administrator in Internet

Makes templates and sequences easy for outreach to prospects

Administrator in Computer Software

The amazing UI, the follow-up reminders and the ability to snooze. Candidly, it's the only email right now built solely for Sales people.

User in Internet

The team behind Reply seem to have a clear product vision and a good understanding of customer needs. Reply combines an extensive features set with a very user-friendly and intuitive interface. It has native integrations with popular CRM products and...

Most Helpful Critical Review
Most Helpful Critical Review
Charles C.
User in Marketing and Advertising

they offered me an account at $85 so i signed up. for subsequent accounts that i created for our teammembers, they bumped it up to $28. when i asked them to fixed it they refused.

Jonas C.
Administrator

Search for emails, both on mac and IOS, too slow and not complete Attachments when forwarding. Allways asking for credentials! Attachments in the midle of the txt. Disformating the carachters (ugly emails when red in other email clients) Star Emails...

Jake H.
Agency in Marketing and Advertising

Tread carefully - pricing is not as it seems. You are limited to 3 email accounts, with $00 added per email account per month afterwords. This is not mentioned on the pricing page, now the terms and conditions. The unlimited tier is NOT...

 
Mixmax
Most Helpful Favorable Review
Administrator in Internet

Makes templates and sequences easy for outreach to prospects

Most Helpful Critical Review
Charles C.
User in Marketing and Advertising

they offered me an account at $18 so i signed up. for subsequent accounts that i created for our teammembers, they bumped it up to $33. when i asked them to fixed it they refused.

Polymail
Most Helpful Favorable Review
Administrator in Computer Software

The amazing UI, the follow-up reminders and the ability to snooze. Candidly, it's the only email right now built solely for Sales people.

Most Helpful Critical Review
Jonas C.
Administrator

Search for emails, both on mac and IOS, too slow and not complete Attachments when forwarding. Allways asking for credentials! Attachments in the midle of the txt. Disformating the carachters (ugly emails when red in other email clients) Star Emails...

Reply
Most Helpful Favorable Review
User in Internet

The team behind Reply seem to have a clear product vision and a good understanding of customer needs. Reply combines an extensive features set with a very user-friendly and intuitive interface. It has native integrations with popular CRM products and...

Most Helpful Critical Review
Jake H.
Agency in Marketing and Advertising

Tread carefully - pricing is not as it seems. You are limited to 7 email accounts, with $30 added per email account per month afterwords. This is not mentioned on the pricing page, now the terms and conditions. The unlimited tier is NOT...

Screenshots

 
1 of 4
0 of 7
1 of 3
5 of 1
2 of 7
No screenshots provided
6 of 0
0 of 6
8 of 7
6 of 1
Polymail
No screenshots provided

Videos

 

See how Brex, Gong.io and Rainforest QA use Mixmax to improve their sales and customer success processes.

No videos provided No videos provided
Mixmax

See how Brex, Gong.io and Rainforest QA use Mixmax to improve their sales and customer success processes.

Polymail
No videos provided
Reply
No videos provided

Downloads

  No downloads provided No downloads provided
Polymail
No downloads provided
Reply
No downloads provided
Ask Mixmax a QuestionContact Mixmax Ask Polymail a QuestionContact Polymail Request More InformationRequest More Information