Reduce your software costs by 18% overnight

Compare Ministry Tracker and Tithe.ly Church Management

See this
side-by-side comparison of Ministry Tracker vs. Tithe.ly Church Management
based on preference data from user reviews. Ministry Tracker rates 3.4/5 stars with 5 reviews. By contrast, Tithe.ly Church Management rates 3.8/5 stars with 13 reviews. Each product's score is calculated with real-time data from verified user reviews, to help you make the best choice between these two options, and decide which one is best for your business needs.
Add Product
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
(5)
3.4 out of 5
Ministry Tracker
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
(13)
3.8 out of 5
Tithe.ly Church Management
Star Rating
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
Market Segments
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Small-Business (80.0% of reviews)
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
Small-Business (61.5% of reviews)
Entry Level Price
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
No pricing information available
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
$30 per month
Categories
Shared Categories
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
Ministry Tracker and Tithe.ly Church Management are categorized as Church Management
Unique Categories
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker has no unique categories
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management is categorized as Volunteer Management
Pricing
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker Pricing
Free Trial Unavailable
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management Pricing
100 active adults
$30per month
Bigger plans available starting at...
$120per month
300 active adults
$90per month
200 active adults
$60per month
Free Trial
Ratings
Meets Requirements
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
7.0
Responses: 5
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
8.2
Responses: 11
Ease of Use
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
7.3
Responses: 5
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
7.6
Responses: 11
Ease of Setup
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Not enough data available
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
Not enough data available
Ease of Admin
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Not enough data available
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
Not enough data available
Quality of Support
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Not enough data available
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
8.5
Responses: 8
Ease of Doing Business With
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Not enough data available
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
Not enough data available
Product Direction (% positive)
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
Not enough data available
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
8.9
Responses: 11
Reviewers' Company Size
Reviewers of both Ministry Tracker and Tithe.ly Church Management were most often representing companies in the Small-Business segment.
Small-Business
(50 or fewer emp.)
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
80.0%
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
61.5%
Mid-Market
(51-1000 emp.)
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
20.0%
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
38.5%
Enterprise
(> 1000 emp.)
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker
0%
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management
0%
Reviewers' Industry
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker Industry
Religious Institutions
80.0%
Non-Profit Organization Management
20.0%
Other
0.0%
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management Industry
Religious Institutions
76.9%
Marketing and Advertising
7.7%
Design
7.7%
Civic & Social Organization
7.7%
Other
0.0%
Reviews
Most Helpful Favorable Review
Ministry Tracker
Jessica L.
Administrator in Religious Institutions

The layers and layers of detail that can be added to user accounts is great but the data entry can be tedius

Tithe.ly Church Management
Doug T.
Administrator in Religious Institutions

I like that I can see both a high-level view of the church, with reports and statistics, but at the same time, I can drill down to a very granular view and see how individual people are doing. As a pastor, I need to have both a view for the whole church and...

Most Helpful Critical Review
Ministry Tracker
Stefie D.
Administrator in Non-Profit Organization Management

Some of the fields to fill in are outdated and never used.

Tithe.ly Church Management
Ryan B.
User in Religious Institutions

Some of the attendance tracking and use of forms doesn't quite allow me to access the metrics that I want. For example I want to know if someone comes 50% of the time or more, but don't have a way to track that. Though the folks at Elvanto may be able to...

Discussions
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker Discussions
Monty the Mongoose crying
Ministry Tracker has no discussions with answers
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management Discussions
Monty the Mongoose crying
Tithe.ly Church Management has no discussions with answers
Screenshots
Ministry Tracker
Ministry Tracker Screenshots
No screenshots provided
Tithe.ly Church Management
Tithe.ly Church Management Screenshots
Request More InformationRequest More InformationAsk Tithe.ly Church Management a QuestionContact Tithe.ly Church Management
Need help?
I can help.
Kate
Learning about Business Software?
Ask the community