Reduce your software costs by 18% overnight

Compare ImportOmatic and StarfishETL

See this
side-by-side comparison of ImportOmatic vs. StarfishETL
based on preference data from user reviews. ImportOmatic rates 4.8/5 stars with 14 reviews. By contrast, StarfishETL rates 4.6/5 stars with 36 reviews. Each product's score is calculated with real-time data from verified user reviews, to help you make the best choice between these two options, and decide which one is best for your business needs.
Add Product
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
(14)
4.8 out of 5
ImportOmatic
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
(36)
4.6 out of 5
StarfishETL
Star Rating
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Market Segments
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Small-Business (57.1% of reviews)
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Small-Business (51.6% of reviews)
Entry Level Price
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
No pricing information available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
$1,495

ImportOmatic vs StarfishETL

When assessing the two solutions, reviewers found ImportOmatic easier to use. However, reviewers felt that StarfishETL is easier to set up and do business with overall. Both products were equally easy to administer.

  • ImportOmatic and StarfishETL both meet the requirements of our reviewers at a comparable rate.
  • When comparing quality of ongoing product support, reviewers felt that StarfishETL is the preferred option.
  • For feature updates and roadmaps, our reviewers preferred the direction of ImportOmatic over StarfishETL.
Categories
Shared Categories
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
ImportOmatic and StarfishETL are categorized as On-Premise Data Integration
Unique Categories
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic has no unique categories
StarfishETL
StarfishETL is categorized as iPaaS, ETL Tools, and Cloud Migration
Pricing
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic Pricing
Free Trial Unavailable
StarfishETL
StarfishETL Pricing
Migration
$1,495
Team Integration
$200
Professional Integration
$400
Enterprise Integration
$1,000
Ultimate Integration
$2000/month
Free Trial
Ask a Question

Have questions for ImportOmatic and StarfishETL?

Start a private conversation.
Ratings
Meets Requirements
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
9.3
Responses: 14
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
9.3
Responses: 30
Ease of Use
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
8.6
Responses: 14
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
8.3
Responses: 29
Ease of Setup
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
7.2
Responses: 10
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
8.1
Responses: 23
Ease of Admin
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
8.8
Responses: 10
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
8.8
Responses: 23
Quality of Support
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
9.3
Responses: 12
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
9.6
Responses: 30
Ease of Doing Business With
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
9.5
Responses: 10
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
9.7
Responses: 24
Product Direction (% positive)
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
9.2
Responses: 14
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
8.5
Responses: 31
Features
Admin Tools
Visual Designer
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Data Transformations
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Breadth of Connectors
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Quality of Connectors
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Workflow
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
User Community
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Run Time Capability
Real-Time Integration
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Parallel Processing
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Data Chunker
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Data Masking
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Proactive Monitoring
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Integration Options
Big Data Processing
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Data Virtualization
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Data Lifecycle Management
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Master Data Management
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Hierarchical Data
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Managed File Transfers
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Asynchronous Messaging
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Platform
Test to Production
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Customization
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
APIs
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Internationalization
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Performance and Reliability
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
User Segmentation and Security
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
Not enough data available
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
Not enough data available
Reviewers' Company Size
Reviewers of both ImportOmatic and StarfishETL were most often representing companies in the Small-Business segment.
Small-Business
(50 or fewer emp.)
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
57.1%
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
51.6%
Mid-Market
(51-1000 emp.)
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
28.6%
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
29.0%
Enterprise
(> 1000 emp.)
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic
14.3%
StarfishETL
StarfishETL
19.4%
Reviewers' Industry
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic Industry
Non-Profit Organization Management
35.7%
Higher Education
35.7%
Fund-Raising
14.3%
Think Tanks
7.1%
Human Resources
7.1%
Other
0.0%
StarfishETL
StarfishETL Industry
Computer Software
25.7%
Information Technology and Services
14.3%
Management Consulting
8.6%
Real Estate
5.7%
Financial Services
5.7%
Other
40.0%
Reviews
Most Helpful Favorable Review
ImportOmatic
Regina D.
Administrator in Higher Education

ImportOmatic is much more user friendly than Raiser's Edge Import. You have virtual fields that you can use for information that's the same for the entire import, which saves time building your csv files. The overall speed of ImportOmatic is faster than...

StarfishETL
William Z.
Consultant in Information Technology and Services

Starfish ETL pre-built products maps significantly reduce data migration effort. The product enables point-and-click configurations, while maintaining the ability to perform complex data transformations. The product has substantially improved our data...

Most Helpful Critical Review
Discussions
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic Discussions
Monty the Mongoose crying
ImportOmatic has no discussions with answers
StarfishETL
StarfishETL Discussions
What is ETL?
1 comment
Offical Response from StarfishETL
ETL stands for Extract, Transform, and Load. StarfishETL enables the migration or integration of data between disparate solutions. StarfishETL enables the...Read more
Does your product work for on-premise or cloud solutions?
1 comment
Offical Response from StarfishETL
StarfishETL can enable integration between cloud solutions, on-premise solutions by installing it within your network, or a combination of both.Read more
Do I have to pay for additional connectors?
1 comment
Offical Response from StarfishETL
No, all the connectors are included with your license and as new connectors are added they are included in all future updates.Read more
Screenshots
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic Screenshots
StarfishETL
StarfishETL Screenshots
No screenshots provided
Videos
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic Videos
No videos provided
StarfishETL
StarfishETL Videos
Video Preview

Watch this quick video for an intro on the power of StarfishETL

Downloads
ImportOmatic
ImportOmatic Downloads
No downloads provided
Ask ImportOmatic a QuestionContact ImportOmaticAsk StarfishETL a QuestionContact StarfishETL
Need help?
I can help.
Kate
Learning about Business Software?
Ask the community