Link copied to clipboard

# Cisco Umbrella vs ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG) Comparison - What are their main differences?

Share
[
Export
](/compare/cisco-umbrella/proxysg-and-advanced-secure-gateway-asg/export.csv)

Cisco UmbrellaSymantec ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)[+ Add Product](#)

Pricing

**Cisco Umbrella**

**Contact vendor for details** · Custom

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**
No pricing available

**Pricing Insights**
from reviews

Perceived Cost

**Cisco Umbrella**
$$$$$

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**
Not enough reviews yet

Average Discount

**Cisco Umbrella**
22%

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**
Not enough reviews yet

Uncover valuable pricing insights from real user feedback to improve your shopping experience.
See it for free

Time to Implement

**Cisco Umbrella** 6 months
Based on 100 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**6 months
Based on 100 responses

Return on Investment

**Cisco Umbrella** 6 months
Based on 100 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**6 months
Based on 100 responses

**Pros & Cons**
from reviews

**Cisco Umbrella**
Not enough data

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**
Not enough data

Integrations

**Cisco Umbrella**
[

 ![Product Avatar Image](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/large_detail/large_detail_8fce4cdac434b53f25936f9cbf18d3d1/cisco-meraki.jpg "Product Avatar Image")

Cisco Meraki

](https://www.g2.com/products/cisco-meraki/reviews)[

 ![Product Avatar Image](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/large_detail/large_detail_bf8095de95175316574d734b1f2b2c48/sumo-logic.png "Product Avatar Image")

Sumo Logic

](https://www.g2.com/products/sumo-logic/reviews)[

 ![Product Avatar Image](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/large_detail/large_detail_68b72646d084b3395febeb94ed97dd9b/gritstone-talos.png "Product Avatar Image")

Talos

](https://www.g2.com/products/gritstone-talos/reviews)[
View all
](https://www.g2.com/products/cisco-umbrella/integrations)

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**
Not enough data

**Ratings**
from reviews

Meets Requirements

**Cisco Umbrella**

**8.7** /10

Based on 244 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**

**9.1** /10

Based on 9 responses

Ease of Use

**Cisco Umbrella**

**8.6** /10

Based on 247 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**

**8.3** /10

Based on 9 responses

Ease of Setup

**Cisco Umbrella**

**8.3** /10

Based on 188 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**

**7.5** /10

Based on 6 responses

Ease of Admin

**Cisco Umbrella**

**8.6** /10

Based on 174 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**

**7.8** /10

Based on 6 responses

Quality of Support

**Cisco Umbrella**

**8.5** /10

Based on 233 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**

**8.7** /10

Based on 9 responses

Has the product been a good partner in doing business?

**Cisco Umbrella**

**8.5** /10

Based on 168 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**

**7.5** /10

Based on 6 responses

Product Direction (% positive)

**Cisco Umbrella**

**8.8** /10

Based on 244 responses

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)**

**10.0** /10

Based on 8 responses

**Features**
ratings from reviews

DNS Security Solutions

**8.7** /10

Based on 58 responses

Not enough data

Cloud Edge Security

**9.0** /10

Based on 27 responses

Not enough data

Secure Web Gateways

**8.7** /10

Based on 19 responses

Not enough data

User Insights

**Reviewers' Company Size**

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
23.6%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
46.0%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
30.4%

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
23.6%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
46.0%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
30.4%

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
10.0%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
50.0%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
40.0%

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
10.0%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
50.0%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
40.0%

**Reviewers' Industry**

[![Cisco Umbrella](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_17d330a37bc2914fb3e2655da70c7a34/cisco-umbrella.png "Cisco Umbrella")](https://www.g2.com/products/cisco-umbrella/reviews)
Cisco Umbrella

Information Technology and Services
19.9%

Computer & Network Security
8.8%

Computer Software
6.5%

Telecommunications
6.1%

Banking
4.2%

Other
54.4%

[![ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/6a37117ddd31c91473bc9ed1594c963b/proxysg-and-advanced-secure-gateway-asg.svg "ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)")](https://www.g2.com/products/proxysg-and-advanced-secure-gateway-asg/reviews)
ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)

Telecommunications
20.0%

Information Technology and Services
20.0%

Computer & Network Security
20.0%

Information Services
10.0%

Hospital & Health Care
10.0%

Other
20.0%

Alternatives

**Cisco Umbrella Alternatives**

 ![DNSFilter](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/6331087c65e8729f438908cbbfa2179d/dnsfilter.svg "DNSFilter")

[
DNSFilter
](/products/dnsfilter/reviews)

 ![Netskope One Platform](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/24f85b7cc708f49da8b235966df41a33/netskope-one-platform.svg "Netskope One Platform")

[
Netskope One Platform
](/products/netskope-one-platform/reviews)

 ![WebTitan Web Filter](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/1553620118/webtitan-web-filter.svg "WebTitan Web Filter")

[
WebTitan Web Filter
](/products/webtitan-web-filter/reviews)

 ![Zscaler Internet Access](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/f063065622874e0a8214c8615c634d1e/zscaler-internet-access.svg "Zscaler Internet Access")

[
Zscaler Internet Access
](/products/zscaler-internet-access/reviews)

**ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG) Alternatives**

 ![Zscaler Internet Access](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/f063065622874e0a8214c8615c634d1e/zscaler-internet-access.svg "Zscaler Internet Access")

[
Zscaler Internet Access
](/products/zscaler-internet-access/reviews)

 ![ThreatLocker Zero Trust Platform](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/2e500391e9bcc35588c7be8bc6b63bbc/threatlocker-zero-trust-platform.svg "ThreatLocker Zero Trust Platform")

[
ThreatLocker Zero Trust Platform
](/products/threatlocker-zero-trust-platform/reviews)

 ![DNSFilter](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/6331087c65e8729f438908cbbfa2179d/dnsfilter.svg "DNSFilter")

[
DNSFilter
](/products/dnsfilter/reviews)

 ![Check Point SASE](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/64ff8da1b6e6ffabf4336ae2510e8e3e/check-point-sase.svg "Check Point SASE")

[
Check Point SASE
](/products/check-point-sase/reviews)

## Cisco Umbrella vs ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG)

When assessing the two solutions, reviewers found Cisco Umbrella easier to use, set up, and administer. Reviewers also preferred doing business with Cisco Umbrella overall.

- Reviewers felt that ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG) meets the needs of their business better than Cisco Umbrella.
- When comparing quality of ongoing product support, reviewers felt that ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG) is the preferred option.
- For feature updates and roadmaps, our reviewers preferred the direction of ProxySG and Advanced Secure Gateway (ASG) over Cisco Umbrella.