Link copied to clipboard

# ChurchStaq vs Planning Center Giving Comparison - What are their main differences?

Share
[
Export
](/compare/churchstaq/planning-center-giving/export.csv)

PushpayPlanning Center Giving[+ Add Product](#)

Reviews

**ChurchStaq** [

4/5(117)

](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews#reviews)

**Planning Center Giving** [

4.5/5(19)

](https://www.g2.com/products/planning-center-giving/reviews#reviews)

Pricing

**ChurchStaq**
No pricing available

**Planning Center Giving**
Free Trial

**Free** 10 Donations · 10 Monthly Donations

**Pricing Insights**
from reviews

Time to Implement

**ChurchStaq**
3 months

Based on 41 responses

**Planning Center Giving**
Not enough reviews yet

Return on Investment

**ChurchStaq**
13 months

Based on 26 responses

**Planning Center Giving**
Not enough reviews yet

Perceived Cost

**ChurchStaq**
$$$$$

**Planning Center Giving**
$$$$$

Average Discount

**ChurchStaq**
11%

**Planning Center Giving**
Not enough reviews yet

 ![ChurchStaq](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/649088c44998d0ce9b960c2f0c9f7f9e/churchstaq.svg "ChurchStaq")

 ![Planning Center Giving](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/f116e3e8497130eb7716c4fd97d9baae/planning-center-giving.svg "Planning Center Giving")

G2 offers free advice on this comparison.

Chat with an expert

How would you like to receive Software Advice?

 ![](/assets/advisor_router/laptop_form-f1a7012279826105416befde8d882ffc7589b1f9db09c93a1379d601cafe8e0d.svg)

FormAnswer questions at your own pace, no call required.

 ![](/assets/advisor_router/ai_agent-4d78629a3ba354fed449a65c60df3a6f2eda90fb98411b711df4b25d7be52a38.svg)

AI AgentChat live and get a recommendation in minutes.

 ![](/assets/advisor_router/phone_call_picker-c48821ec36f4182d8ee3e54cfbd3937500eec54d7b7e0cfb80dc80a8a733842f.svg)

Phone CallTalk it through live with a software advisor.

Pros & Cons

**ChurchStaq**
[
Ease of Use (2)
](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=2374062&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
All-in-one Solution (1)
](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=2374088&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
Expensive (2)
](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=1945747&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)[
Credit Issues (1)
](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews?filters%5Bsentiment_snippet%5D=2374045&qs=pros-and-cons#reviews)

**Planning Center Giving**
Not enough data

Integrations

**ChurchStaq**
Not enough data

**Planning Center Giving**
[

 ![Product Avatar Image](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/large_detail/large_detail_1cce7b134937073a8f4888c2c8a5aac1/mortarstone.png "Product Avatar Image")

MortarStone

](https://www.g2.com/products/mortarstone/reviews)[
View all
](https://www.g2.com/products/planning-center-giving/integrations)

Ratings

Meets Requirements

**ChurchStaq**

8.3

8.3107

**Planning Center Giving**

9.3

9.315

Ease of Use

**ChurchStaq**

7.9

7.9107

**Planning Center Giving**

9.3

9.315

Ease of Setup

**ChurchStaq**

7.6

7.666

**Planning Center Giving**

8.9

8.99

Ease of Admin

**ChurchStaq**

7.7

7.768

**Planning Center Giving**

9.1

9.19

Quality of Support

**ChurchStaq**

8.4

8.4101

**Planning Center Giving**

9.4

9.412

Has the product been a good partner in doing business?

**ChurchStaq**

8.6

8.665

**Planning Center Giving**

9.4

9.49

Product Direction (% positive)

**ChurchStaq**

8.1

8.1106

**Planning Center Giving**

9.2

9.215

Features

Show 3 feature categories with incomplete data

Nonprofit[Hide 47 FeaturesShow 47 Features](javascript:void(0);)

Not enough data

Not enough data

Additional Functionality

Activity Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Social Marketing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Generative AI

Not enough data

Not enough data

Accounting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Reports

Not enough data

Not enough data

CRM

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Forms

Not enough data

Not enough data

Fund Accounting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Forms Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Analytics

Not enough data

Not enough data

Member Database

Not enough data

Not enough data

Alerts/Notifications

Not enough data

Not enough data

Communication Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Templates

Not enough data

Not enough data

Budgeting/Forecasting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Mobile Access

Not enough data

Not enough data

Event Scheduling

Not enough data

Not enough data

Donor Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Attendance Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Dashboard

Not enough data

Not enough data

Reporting & Statistics

Not enough data

Not enough data

Volunteer Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Reporting

Not enough data

Not enough data

For Nonprofits

Not enough data

Not enough data

Recurring/Subscription Billing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Access Controls/Permissions

Not enough data

Not enough data

Calendar Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Third-Party Integrations

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Branding

Not enough data

Not enough data

Registration Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Campaign Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Event Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Document Storage

Not enough data

Not enough data

API

Not enough data

Not enough data

Contact Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Website Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Credit Card Processing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Membership Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Data Import/Export

Not enough data

Not enough data

Electronic Payments

Not enough data

Not enough data

Accounting Integration

Not enough data

Not enough data

Grant Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Dues Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Committee Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

AI Copilot

Not enough data

Not enough data

Fundraising Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Fields

Not enough data

Not enough data

Donor Management[Hide 55 FeaturesShow 55 Features](javascript:void(0);)

Not enough data

Not enough data

Administration

User Dashboard

Not enough data

Not enough data

Donor Profiles

Not enough data

Not enough data

Reporting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Templates

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customization

Not enough data

Not enough data

Ad hoc Reporting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Dashboard

Not enough data

Not enough data

Donor Management

Moves Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Pledge Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

E-Document Storage

Not enough data

Not enough data

Acknowledgments & Communications

Not enough data

Not enough data

Multi-Channel Communication

Not enough data

Not enough data

Donor Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Receipt Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Email Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Volunteer Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Registration Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Gift Matching Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Event Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Grant Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Attendance Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Contact Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Pledge Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Forms Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Campaign Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Interoperability

Event Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Gift Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Fund Accounting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Donation Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Additional Functionality

Online Giving

Not enough data

Not enough data

Summary Reports

Not enough data

Not enough data

Mobile Access

Not enough data

Not enough data

Email Marketing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Forms

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Branding

Not enough data

Not enough data

Historical Trend Analysis

Not enough data

Not enough data

API

Not enough data

Not enough data

Recurring Giving

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Fields

Not enough data

Not enough data

Reporting/Analytics

Not enough data

Not enough data

For Nonprofits

Not enough data

Not enough data

Recurring/Subscription Billing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Mobile Giving

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Reports

Not enough data

Not enough data

Event Ticketing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Third-Party Integrations

Not enough data

Not enough data

AI Copilot

Not enough data

Not enough data

Campaign Planning

Not enough data

Not enough data

Access Controls/Permissions

Not enough data

Not enough data

Personalization

Not enough data

Not enough data

Credit Card Processing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Payment Processing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Generative AI

Not enough data

Not enough data

Data Import/Export

Not enough data

Not enough data

Church Management[Hide 82 FeaturesShow 82 Features](javascript:void(0);)

Not enough data

Not enough data

Platform Basics

Membership Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Donation Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Congregation Communication

Not enough data

Not enough data

Worship Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Event Planning

Not enough data

Not enough data

Church Accounting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Volunteer Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Financial Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Asset Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Expense Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Time & Expense Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Sales Tax Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Attendance Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Cash Flow Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Receipt Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Purchase Order Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Membership Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Invoice Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Compliance Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Registration Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Contact Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Communication Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Worship Planning

Not enough data

Not enough data

Attendance Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Visitor Tracking

Not enough data

Not enough data

Forms Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Website Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Small Group Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Platform Additional Functionality

People Management Specific Tools

Not enough data

Not enough data

Event Management Specific Tools

Not enough data

Not enough data

Payroll Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Cash Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Pledge Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Email Management

Not enough data

Not enough data

Agentic AI - Church Management

Autonomous Task Execution

Not enough data

Not enough data

Cross-system Integration

Not enough data

Not enough data

Natural Language Interaction

Not enough data

Not enough data

Proactive Assistance

Not enough data

Not enough data

Third-Party Integrations

Not enough data

Not enough data

Accounting Integration

Not enough data

Not enough data

Social Media Integration

Not enough data

Not enough data

Additional Functionality

Event Scheduling

Not enough data

Not enough data

Multi-Currency

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Data

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Branding

Not enough data

Not enough data

Data Import/Export

Not enough data

Not enough data

Mobile Access

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Templates

Not enough data

Not enough data

Recurring/Subscription Billing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Bank Reconciliation

Not enough data

Not enough data

Financial Reporting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Real-Time Reporting

Not enough data

Not enough data

Transaction History

Not enough data

Not enough data

For Religious Organizations

Not enough data

Not enough data

Financial Analysis

Not enough data

Not enough data

Budgeting/Forecasting

Not enough data

Not enough data

AI Copilot

Not enough data

Not enough data

Accounts Receivable

Not enough data

Not enough data

Credit Card Processing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Invoice Processing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Electronic Payments

Not enough data

Not enough data

ACH Payment Processing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Customizable Reports

Not enough data

Not enough data

Reminders

Not enough data

Not enough data

Accounts Payable

Not enough data

Not enough data

Reporting & Statistics

Not enough data

Not enough data

General Ledger

Not enough data

Not enough data

Billing & Invoicing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Generative AI

Not enough data

Not enough data

Activity Dashboard

Not enough data

Not enough data

API

Not enough data

Not enough data

Check Printing

Not enough data

Not enough data

Multi-Location

Not enough data

Not enough data

Alerts/Notifications

Not enough data

Not enough data

Member Portal

Not enough data

Not enough data

Child Check-in

Not enough data

Not enough data

Online Giving

Not enough data

Not enough data

Member Directory

Not enough data

Not enough data

SMS Messaging

Not enough data

Not enough data

Contact Database

Not enough data

Not enough data

Online Calendar

Not enough data

Not enough data

Role-Based Permissions

Not enough data

Not enough data

User Insights

Reviewers' Company Size

[![ChurchStaq](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/649088c44998d0ce9b960c2f0c9f7f9e/churchstaq.svg "ChurchStaq")](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews)

ChurchStaq

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)

82.8%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)

16.4%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)

0.9%

[![Planning Center Giving](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/f116e3e8497130eb7716c4fd97d9baae/planning-center-giving.svg "Planning Center Giving")](https://www.g2.com/products/planning-center-giving/reviews)

Planning Center Giving

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)

100.0%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)

0%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)

0%

Small-Business

(50 or fewer emp.)

82.8%

100.0%

Mid-Market

(51-1000 emp.)

16.4%

0%

Enterprise

(\> 1000 emp.)

0.9%

0%

Reviewers' Industry

[![ChurchStaq](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/649088c44998d0ce9b960c2f0c9f7f9e/churchstaq.svg "ChurchStaq")](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews)
ChurchStaq

Religious Institutions

70.7%

Non-Profit Organization Management

19.0%

Marketing and Advertising

1.7%

Consumer Services

1.7%

Public Safety

0.9%

Other

6.0%

[![Planning Center Giving](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/f116e3e8497130eb7716c4fd97d9baae/planning-center-giving.svg "Planning Center Giving")](https://www.g2.com/products/planning-center-giving/reviews)
Planning Center Giving

Religious Institutions

66.7%

Non-Profit Organization Management

27.8%

Hospitality

5.6%

‐

‐

Other

0.0%

FAQs

## Pushpay vs Planning Center Giving FAQs

Generated using AI

Last updated: August 14, 2026

### What is the difference between Pushpay vs Planning Center Giving?

Planning Center Giving is rated higher than Pushpay by G2 reviewers, with stronger scores for setup and support.

| [Pushpay](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews) | [Planning Center Giving](https://www.g2.com/products/planning-center-giving/reviews) |
| --- | --- |
| 4.0/5 (117 reviews) | 4.5/5 (19 reviews) |
| Small-Business | Small-Business |
| 7.6 | 8.9 |
| 8.4 | 9.4 |
| Ease of Use (2 all-time mentions) | — |

### How do the pricing models of Pushpay and Planning Center Giving compare?

Planning Center Giving is rated higher for value, with reviewers expressing greater satisfaction with its pricing.

- **Pushpay:** Reviewers frequently cite high costs and expensive fees as a drawback, with several switching to alternatives to save thousands of dollars in tithes and offerings.
- **Planning Center Giving:** Reviewers highlight lower fees and a favorable price point, with one noting the cost is scalable based on congregation size.
- **Switching reasons:** Recent Pushpay reviewers mention moving to other platforms like SecureGive to reduce costs.

### What are the best alternatives to Pushpay and Planning Center Giving?

The top 3 alternatives to Pushpay and Planning Center Giving are Planning Center Services, Subsplash, and SecureGive.

| Product | G2 Rating (reviews) | Largest Segment | Pricing Insight | Top Reviewer-Cited Strength |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Pushpay](https://www.g2.com/products/churchstaq/reviews) | 4.0/5 (117 reviews) | Small-Business | Reviewers cite high costs and expensive fees | Ease of Use (2 all-time mentions) |
| [Planning Center Giving](https://www.g2.com/products/planning-center-giving/reviews) | 4.5/5 (19 reviews) | Small-Business | Reviewers highlight lower fees and scalable pricing | Integration with Planning Center suite |
| [Planning Center Services](https://www.g2.com/products/planning-center-services/reviews) | 4.7/5 (181 reviews) | Small-Business | — | Comprehensive church management features |
| [Subsplash](https://www.g2.com/products/subsplash/reviews) | 4.1/5 (28 reviews) | Small-Business | — | — |

### Which Church Management features should I prioritize when comparing Pushpay and Planning Center Giving?

Buyers should prioritize Ease of Use, Ease of Setup, Quality of Support, Integrations, and Pricing when comparing Pushpay and Planning Center Giving.

- **Ease of Use:** Pushpay 7.9, Planning Center Giving 9.3
- **Ease of Setup:** Pushpay 7.6, Planning Center Giving 8.9
- **Quality of Support:** Pushpay 8.4, Planning Center Giving 9.4
- **Integrations:** Pushpay has 1 all-time mention for integrations; Planning Center Giving is frequently praised for integration with the Planning Center suite.
- **Pricing:** Pushpay is frequently cited for high costs; Planning Center Giving is highlighted for lower fees and scalable pricing.

### What are the pros and cons of Pushpay vs Planning Center Giving?

Pushpay's headline strength is ease of use, while Planning Center Giving is praised for integration and value.

- **Pushpay strengths:** Ease of Use (2 all-time mentions), all-in-one solution, customization, features, flexibility, integrations, user interface.
- **Pushpay trade-offs:** Expensive (1 all-time mention), high fees (1), outdated design (1), integration issues (1), poor mobile functionality (1), inefficiency (1), restrictive contracts, slow or poor customer service, incomplete setup for some users.
- **Planning Center Giving strengths:** Integration with the Planning Center suite, ease of use, scalable pricing, easy setup, strong support, centralized record-keeping, and automated reporting.
- **Planning Center Giving trade-offs:** Some reviewers note slower backend processing, limited reporting and generosity development features, and challenges with joint household giving.

### Is Pushpay or Planning Center Giving better for small businesses?

Planning Center Giving is the better fit for small businesses, with higher satisfaction scores and strong small-business reviewer sentiment.

- **Pushpay:** Small-Business segment; reviewers note ease of use but frequently cite high costs and restrictive contracts as drawbacks for smaller organizations.
- **Planning Center Giving:** Small-Business segment; reviewers highlight ease of setup, integration with other Planning Center tools, and scalable pricing as key benefits for small churches.

### Which Church Management platform has better integrations?

Planning Center Giving is favored for integrations, especially with the Planning Center suite.

- **Pushpay:** Integrations are mentioned in reviews, but integration issues are also cited as a trade-off.
- **Planning Center Giving:** Reviewers consistently praise its integration with the full Planning Center suite, enabling unified management of giving, people, and events.

### How do Pushpay and Planning Center Giving compare on customer support?

Planning Center Giving outperforms Pushpay on Quality of Support by a full point (9.4 vs 8.4), a material difference.

- **Pushpay:** Reviewers report slow or poor customer service, with some citing long response times and reliance on support for changes.
- **Planning Center Giving:** Reviewers highlight strong support, quick responses, and helpful resources, with multiple reviews rating support at the highest level.

### Which is easier to implement, Pushpay or Planning Center Giving?

Planning Center Giving is easier to implement, with a 1.3-point higher Ease of Setup score (8.9 vs 7.6).

- **Pushpay:** Reviewers report a mix of experiences, with some finding setup easy and others citing incomplete setup after extended use or a lengthy learning curve.
- **Planning Center Giving:** Reviewers consistently describe setup as easy, with several noting quick onboarding and smooth transitions, especially for small churches.

Alternatives

**ChurchStaq Alternatives**

 ![Planning Center Services](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/f116e3e8497130eb7716c4fd97d9baae/planning-center-services.svg "Planning Center Services")

[
Planning Center Services
](/products/planning-center-services/reviews)

 ![Subsplash](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_0ea498112df0a04693c3daab08a2ea30/subsplash.png "Subsplash")

[
Subsplash
](/products/subsplash/reviews)

 ![Realm](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/1516721238/realm.svg "Realm")

[
Realm
](/products/realm/reviews)

 ![Breeze ChMS](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/3b76d541b22e33b909cd1fca1d0f5904/breeze.svg "Breeze ChMS")

[
Breeze ChMS
](/products/yourgiving-inc-breeze-chms/reviews)

**Planning Center Giving Alternatives**

 ![Subsplash](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_0ea498112df0a04693c3daab08a2ea30/subsplash.png "Subsplash")

[
Subsplash
](/products/subsplash/reviews)

 ![Text-Em-All](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/aa2f7e22d852c96e56edb3ed0fd8e97f/text-em-all.svg "Text-Em-All")

[
Text-Em-All
](/products/text-em-all/reviews)

 ![DonorPerfect](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/97d98d389d1fa793bdbbdb50169fe1ae/donorperfect.svg "DonorPerfect")

[
DonorPerfect
](/products/donorperfect/reviews)

 ![NetSuite](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/4b02508eaf1eed7c1c991b5f0ce3fab7/oracle-netsuite.svg "NetSuite")

[
NetSuite
](/products/oracle-netsuite/reviews)