Link copied to clipboard

# Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield Comparison - What are their main differences?

Last updated: November 14, 2026

Share
[
Export
](/compare/allstate-identity-protection/id-shield/export.csv)

Allstate Identity ProtectionID Shield[+ Add Product](#)

Pricing

**Allstate Identity Protection**
No pricing available

**ID Shield**
No pricing available

**Pros & Cons**
from reviews

**Allstate Identity Protection**
Not enough data

**ID Shield**
Not enough data

Screenshots

**Allstate Identity Protection**
 ![Allstate Identity Protection screenshot](https://images.g2crowd.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=600,height=600,fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,/https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/attachment/file/138587/AIP-Laptop-Phone-01_1_.jpg)

**ID Shield**
No screenshot available

**Ratings**
from reviews

Meets Requirements

**Allstate Identity Protection**

**9.3** /10

Based on 12 responses

**ID Shield**

**8.8** /10

Based on 10 responses

Ease of Use

**Allstate Identity Protection**

**9.2** /10

Based on 12 responses

**ID Shield**

**8.7** /10

Based on 9 responses

Ease of Setup

**Allstate Identity Protection**

**9.5** /10

Based on 11 responses

**ID Shield**

**8.6** /10

Based on 7 responses

Ease of Admin

**Allstate Identity Protection** Not enough data

**ID Shield** Not enough data

Quality of Support

**Allstate Identity Protection**

**9.2** /10

Based on 11 responses

**ID Shield**

**7.9** /10

Based on 7 responses

Has the product been a good partner in doing business?

**Allstate Identity Protection** Not enough data

**ID Shield** Not enough data

Product Direction (% positive)

**Allstate Identity Protection**

**8.1** /10

Based on 12 responses

**ID Shield**

**8.8** /10

Based on 10 responses

**Features**
ratings from reviews

Employee Identity Theft Protection

**8.8** /10

Based on 11 responses

**8.6** /10

Based on 8 responses

##### Latest reviews from Allstate Identity Protection & ID Shield

 ![Allstate Identity Protection](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/large_detail/large_detail_c94cc3878d93e7e1c2db7afec3e38583/allstate-identity-protection.jpg "Allstate Identity Protection")

### Allstate Identity Protection

CS

reviewed by [Carolina S.](https://www.g2.com/users/348a96c2-3e7f-49c4-b10f-95e626a0bea1)

Administrative assistant | Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

* * *

5/5

"Gives you a piece of mind that your personal information is safe."

It helps follow and track your personal information.

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews/allstate-identity-protection-review-11718399)about 1 year ago

reviewed by Verified User

Enterprise (\> 1000 emp.)

* * *

5/5

"Glad that this is in the reality now"

The fact that we need this is something that we haven't thought a few years ago. But I'm glad that we have this now to safeguard our online presence. I will surely recommend thi...

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews/allstate-identity-protection-review-10069514)about 2 years ago

 ![Shammi R.](/assets/transparent-ad5be28fbcd25b7b08d2cebe1d957125437fb5407d75ee717965ad22c8808791.gif "Shammi R.")
SR

reviewed by [Shammi R.](https://www.g2.com/users/5546af3e-2613-4b4d-93b2-94490d37595f)

Sr. Executive, Digital Marketing | Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

* * *

5/5

"Allstate Identity Protection Review"

What I like best about Allstate Identity Protection is their comprehensive support and proactive approach to safeguarding personal information.

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews/allstate-identity-protection-review-10067629)about 2 years ago

 ![Hasnat A.](/assets/transparent-ad5be28fbcd25b7b08d2cebe1d957125437fb5407d75ee717965ad22c8808791.gif "Hasnat A.")
HA

reviewed by [Hasnat A.](https://www.g2.com/users/dcaeb842-1d4e-41eb-ad28-816caa7f3ce5)

Back End Developer | Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

* * *

4/5

"Identity protection is critical."

The simplicity and ease of use. The implementation is a piece of cake. Brilliant customer support and the way I shop and login to different account like 20-30 times. The vast fe...

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews/allstate-identity-protection-review-10067603)about 2 years ago

AM

reviewed by [Abdul M.](https://www.g2.com/users/f229cbfe-5919-43a4-8630-717856ebb7ab)

Information Security Analyst | Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

* * *

4/5

"Reliable Protection, Minor User Interface Improvements"

Allstate Identity Protection offers comprehensive coverage that instills confidence in safeguarding personal information. The real-time monitoring and alerts provide peace of mi...

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews/allstate-identity-protection-review-10032280)about 2 years ago

 ![ID Shield](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/large_detail/large_detail_fa9e0a2d55623a4ec07981b398a515a4/id-shield.gif "ID Shield")

### ID Shield

RH

reviewed by [Randa H.](https://www.g2.com/users/a46d526a-546a-4292-b673-44131f6fea6f)

Head of Legal Affairs | Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

* * *

4.5/5

"Provides total protection from identity theft"

ID Shield tracks a broad range of information that includes things as common as Social Security numbers and credit cards to things as specific as medical identification numbers ...

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews/id-shield-review-10608259)almost 2 years ago

 ![Katie L.](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/a/ACg8ocIGxKC5iebvWWnFpIoCI7vxA6E1vo5iF7BMEq8PAV7x4HNBvQ=s96-c "Katie L.")
KL

reviewed by [Katie L.](https://www.g2.com/users/f19899f7-0db5-45cf-a510-3abd844578cd)

Assistant Business Manager | Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

* * *

4.5/5

"Easy to set up account & great for even daily use"

You will be alerted of changes in your credit scores, if you have applied for credit and if your information has been compromised

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews/id-shield-review-10566406)almost 2 years ago

reviewed by Verified User

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

* * *

2.5/5

"It was ok"

I felt secure in the event of identity theft

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews/id-shield-review-10566372)almost 2 years ago

reviewed by Verified User

Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

* * *

5/5

"ID Shield Is Great"

Easy to use and makes me feel safe knowing my personal information is protected

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews/id-shield-review-10396761)about 2 years ago

reviewed by Verified User

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

* * *

2.5/5

"The end user product is good, but the platform for administration is not great"

The end user has good things to say. The service you are buying is what you get.

[
Read full review
](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews/id-shield-review-10408063)about 2 years ago

User Insights

**Reviewers' Company Size**

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
66.7%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
16.7%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
16.7%

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
66.7%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
16.7%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
16.7%

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
50.0%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
40.0%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
10.0%

Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.)
50.0%

Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.)
40.0%

Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.)
10.0%

**Reviewers' Industry**

[![Allstate Identity Protection](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_c94cc3878d93e7e1c2db7afec3e38583/allstate-identity-protection.jpg "Allstate Identity Protection")](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews)
Allstate Identity Protection

Information Technology and Services
25.0%

Insurance
16.7%

Computer & Network Security
16.7%

Retail
8.3%

Restaurants
8.3%

Other
25.0%

[![ID Shield](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_fa9e0a2d55623a4ec07981b398a515a4/id-shield.gif "ID Shield")](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews)
ID Shield

Insurance
20.0%

Retail
10.0%

Religious Institutions
10.0%

Real Estate
10.0%

Human Resources
10.0%

Other
40.0%

Alternatives

**Allstate Identity Protection Alternatives**

 ![Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_edcfae5427908321d9423efcad1f8cdc/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions.jpeg "Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions")

[
Norton LifeLock Benefit...
](/products/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions/reviews)

 ![IDX](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_a3c64b81c576dfe657ca1486c909aecd/idx.jpeg "IDX")

[
IDX
](/products/idx/reviews)

 ![Identity Guard](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_2ebe093e124274cd99eb064ef1895d5a/identity-guard.jpg "Identity Guard")

[
Identity Guard
](/products/identity-guard/reviews)

 ![Agency](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/ed60aec5c35fc2bd7597f43a3eed0896/agency-2025-12-16.svg "Agency")

[
Agency
](/products/agency-2025-12-16/reviews)

**ID Shield Alternatives**

 ![Identity Guard](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_2ebe093e124274cd99eb064ef1895d5a/identity-guard.jpg "Identity Guard")

[
Identity Guard
](/products/identity-guard/reviews)

 ![Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_edcfae5427908321d9423efcad1f8cdc/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions.jpeg "Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions")

[
Norton LifeLock Benefit...
](/products/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions/reviews)

 ![IdentityIQ](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_21489edcecccd64b49a016f688fd016d/identityiq.png "IdentityIQ")

[
IdentityIQ
](/products/identityiq/reviews)

 ![Agency](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/ed60aec5c35fc2bd7597f43a3eed0896/agency-2025-12-16.svg "Agency")

[
Agency
](/products/agency-2025-12-16/reviews)

## Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield FAQs

Generated using AI

### What is the difference between Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield?

Allstate Identity Protection leads ID Shield on G2’s overall rating, setup, and support scores, while both products earn strong reviewer ratings.

| Dimension | [Allstate Identity Protection](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews) | [ID Shield](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| G2 Rating (reviews) | 4.8/5 | 4.3/5 |
| Ease of Setup score | 9.5 | 8.6 |
| Quality of Support score | 9.2 | 7.9 |
| Top Reviewer-Cited Strength | Proactive monitoring, timely alerts, and remediation support | Broad monitoring of personal information and identity restoration assistance |

### How do the pricing models of Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield compare?

Allstate Identity Protection is the stronger value on reviewer satisfaction, with a higher Meets Requirements score of 9.3 versus ID Shield’s 8.8.

- **Allstate Identity Protection:** In recent reviews, reviewers describe comprehensive coverage, real-time alerts, and fraud-resolution support as valuable benefits.
- **ID Shield:** Recent reviewers value the protection and identity-restoration service, while one reviewer says the cost feels high relative to perceived value.

### What are the best alternatives to Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield?

The top alternatives to Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield are Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions, IDX, and Identity Guard.

| Product | G2 Rating (reviews) | Largest Segment | Top Reviewer-Cited Strength |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Allstate Identity Protection](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews) | 4.8/5 | | Proactive monitoring, timely alerts, and remediation support |
| [ID Shield](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews) | 4.3/5 | | Broad monitoring of personal information and identity restoration assistance |
| [Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions](https://www.g2.com/products/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions/reviews) | 4.6/5 | | |
| [IDX](https://www.g2.com/products/idx/reviews) | 4.4/5 | Small-Business | |
| [Identity Guard](https://www.g2.com/products/identity-guard/reviews) | 4.3/5 | | |

### Which Employee Identity Theft Protection features should I prioritize when comparing Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield?

Prioritize monitoring breadth, alert quality, identity restoration, ease of use, and support when evaluating Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield.

- **Monitoring breadth:** Recent ID Shield reviews cite monitoring Social Security numbers, credit cards, medical identification numbers, professional licenses, and social media accounts; Allstate reviewers cite personal-information and credit monitoring.
- **Alert quality:** Allstate reviewers value timely alerts and readable reports; ID Shield reviewers value credit and compromise alerts, though one recent reviewer reports frequent false alarms.
- **Identity restoration:** Allstate reviewers praise its dedicated fraud-resolution team; ID Shield reviewers describe assistance from licensed private investigators.
- **Ease of use:** Allstate scores 9.2 and ID Shield scores 8.7.
- **Support:** Allstate scores 9.2 and ID Shield scores 7.9.

### What are the pros and cons of Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield?

Allstate Identity Protection’s headline strength is proactive monitoring with responsive fraud-resolution support; ID Shield’s is broad personal-information monitoring with hands-on restoration assistance.

- **Allstate Identity Protection strengths:** Recent reviewers praise real-time alerts, easy setup, readable notifications, and a dedicated fraud-resolution team.
- **Allstate Identity Protection trade-offs:** Reviewers mention occasional duplicate alerts, login frustration, and a user interface that could be more intuitive.
- **ID Shield strengths:** Recent reviewers value monitoring across varied personal identifiers, credit activity alerts, and identity-restoration assistance.
- **ID Shield trade-offs:** Reviewers cite false-positive alerts, a limited mobile app, configuration effort, and a difficult administrator portal.

### Which Employee Identity Theft Protection platform has better integrations?

Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield are at parity on reviewer-cited integrations, with no integration preference established in their reviews.

- **Allstate Identity Protection:** A recent reviewer says the product integrates easily with their ecosystem, without naming a specific integration.

### How do Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield compare on customer support?

Allstate Identity Protection scores 1.3 points higher than ID Shield on Quality of Support, 9.2 versus 7.9.

- **Allstate Identity Protection:** Recent reviewers praise comprehensive customer support and an efficient, helpful fraud-resolution team; one reviewer requests support in additional languages.
- **ID Shield:** Reviewers describe support experiences ranging from positive to inconsistent, with reports of slower responses and difficulty resolving complex cases.

### Which is easier to implement, Allstate Identity Protection or ID Shield?

Allstate Identity Protection scores 0.9 points higher than ID Shield on Ease of Setup, 9.5 versus 8.6.

- **Allstate Identity Protection:** Recent reviewers describe implementation as easy and household-member setup as straightforward.
- **ID Shield:** Reviewers report that setup can be easy, while one notes that configuring the many features takes time.

### Which product has better Monitoring?

Monitoring is the most frequently mentioned feature across Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield reviews.

- **Allstate Identity Protection:** Recent reviewers describe personal-information and credit monitoring, timely alerts, and reports that help flag potential issues.
- **ID Shield:** Recent reviewers cite monitoring of credit activity and a broad range of identifiers, including Social Security numbers, medical identification numbers, and professional licenses.

## Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield

- Reviewers felt that Allstate Identity Protection meets the needs of their business better than ID Shield.
- When comparing quality of ongoing product support, reviewers felt that Allstate Identity Protection is the preferred option.
- For feature updates and roadmaps, our reviewers preferred the direction of ID Shield over Allstate Identity Protection.