Link copied to clipboard # Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield Comparison - What are their main differences? Share [ Export ](/compare/allstate-identity-protection/id-shield/export.csv) Allstate Identity ProtectionID Shield[+ Add Product](#) Reviews **Allstate Identity Protection** [ 4.8/5(12) ](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews#reviews) **ID Shield** [ 4.3/5(10) ](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews#reviews) Pricing **Allstate Identity Protection** No pricing available **ID Shield** No pricing available **Pricing Insights** from reviews Pros & Cons **Allstate Identity Protection** Not enough data **ID Shield** Not enough data Screenshots **Allstate Identity Protection** ![Allstate Identity Protection screenshot](https://images.g2crowd.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=600,height=600,fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,/https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/attachment/file/138587/AIP-Laptop-Phone-01_1_.jpg) **ID Shield** No screenshot available Ratings Meets Requirements **Allstate Identity Protection** 9.3 9.312 **ID Shield** 8.8 8.810 Ease of Use **Allstate Identity Protection** 9.2 9.212 **ID Shield** 8.7 8.79 Ease of Setup **Allstate Identity Protection** 9.5 9.511 **ID Shield** 8.6 8.67 Ease of Admin **Allstate Identity Protection** Not enough data **ID Shield** Not enough data Quality of Support **Allstate Identity Protection** 9.2 9.211 **ID Shield** 7.9 7.97 Has the product been a good partner in doing business? **Allstate Identity Protection** Not enough data **ID Shield** Not enough data Product Direction (% positive) **Allstate Identity Protection** 8.1 8.112 **ID Shield** 8.8 8.810 Features Employee Identity Theft Protection[Hide 11 FeaturesShow 11 Features](javascript:void(0);) 8.8 11 8.6 8 Platform Basics Reporting 8.5(won by 1.4) 10 (There is a greater than 0.5 difference between this product's rating and its competitors) 7.1 8 Monitoring 9.0(won by 0.9) 10 (There is a greater than 0.5 difference between this product's rating and its competitors) 8.1 8 Performance 9.3(won by 0.3) 10 9.0 8 Platform Content Proactive monitoring 9.2(tied score) 10 9.2(tied score) 8 Breach notification 9.0 10 9.4(won by 0.4) 8 Compliance 9.3(won by 0.8) 10 (There is a greater than 0.5 difference between this product's rating and its competitors) 8.5 8 Platform Additional Functionality Dashboard 9.0(tied score) 10 9.0(tied score) 8 Messaging 8.7(won by 0.4) 10 8.3 8 Portal 8.5(won by 0.2) 9 8.3 8 Integrations 7.8 9 8.1(won by 0.3) 8 Educational Resources 8.3 9 9.2(won by 0.9) 8 (There is a greater than 0.5 difference between this product's rating and its competitors) User Insights Reviewers' Company Size [![Allstate Identity Protection](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_c94cc3878d93e7e1c2db7afec3e38583/allstate-identity-protection.jpg "Allstate Identity Protection")](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews) Allstate Identity Protection Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.) 66.7% Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.) 16.7% Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.) 16.7% [![ID Shield](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_fa9e0a2d55623a4ec07981b398a515a4/id-shield.gif "ID Shield")](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews) ID Shield Small-Business(50 or fewer emp.) 50.0% Mid-Market(51-1000 emp.) 40.0% Enterprise(\> 1000 emp.) 10.0% Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.) 66.7% 50.0% Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.) 16.7% 40.0% Enterprise (\> 1000 emp.) 16.7% 10.0% Reviewers' Industry [![Allstate Identity Protection](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_c94cc3878d93e7e1c2db7afec3e38583/allstate-identity-protection.jpg "Allstate Identity Protection")](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews) Allstate Identity Protection Information Technology and Services 25.0% Insurance 16.7% Computer & Network Security 16.7% Retail 8.3% Restaurants 8.3% Other 25.0% [![ID Shield](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_fa9e0a2d55623a4ec07981b398a515a4/id-shield.gif "ID Shield")](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews) ID Shield Insurance 20.0% Retail 10.0% Religious Institutions 10.0% Real Estate 10.0% Human Resources 10.0% Other 40.0% FAQs ## Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield FAQs Generated using AI Last updated: August 17, 2026 ### What is the difference between Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield? Allstate Identity Protection stands out for higher reviewer satisfaction across key dimensions compared to ID Shield. | [Allstate Identity Protection](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews) | [ID Shield](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews) | | --- | --- | | G2 Rating (reviews): 4.8/5 (12) | G2 Rating (reviews): 4.3/5 (10) | | Ease of Setup: 9.5 | Ease of Setup: 8.6 | | Quality of Support: 9.2 | Quality of Support: 7.9 | | Top Reviewer-Cited Strength: Comprehensive support and proactive monitoring | Top Reviewer-Cited Strength: Broad monitoring coverage including medical IDs and professional licenses | ### How do the pricing models of Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield compare? Allstate Identity Protection is rated higher for value, with reviewers expressing greater satisfaction with its pricing compared to ID Shield. - **Allstate Identity Protection:** In recent reviews, users highlight confidence in the value provided, citing comprehensive coverage and peace of mind as key benefits. - **ID Shield:** Recent reviewers mention that the perceived value does not always match the cost, with some noting the annual renewal as a drawback. ### What are the best alternatives to Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield? The top three alternatives to Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield are Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions, Identity Guard, and — (no third alternative supported in the data). | Product | G2 Rating (reviews) | Pricing Insight | Top Reviewer-Cited Strength | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | [Allstate Identity Protection](https://www.g2.com/products/allstate-identity-protection/reviews) | 4.8/5 (12) | — | Comprehensive support and proactive monitoring | | [ID Shield](https://www.g2.com/products/id-shield/reviews) | 4.3/5 (10) | Cost to perceived value is a concern for some reviewers | Broad monitoring coverage including medical IDs and professional licenses | | [Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions](https://www.g2.com/products/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions/reviews) | 4.6/5 (13) | — | — | | [Identity Guard](https://www.g2.com/products/identity-guard/reviews) | 4.3/5 (10) | — | — | ### Which Employee Identity Theft Protection features should I prioritize when comparing Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield? Buyers should prioritize Monitoring, Ease of Setup, Quality of Support, and Coverage Breadth when comparing Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield. - **Monitoring:** Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield both receive frequent positive mentions for monitoring, with Allstate Identity Protection noted for proactive alerts and ID Shield for broad coverage including medical and professional IDs. - **Ease of Setup:** Allstate Identity Protection scores 9.5, while ID Shield scores 8.6. - **Quality of Support:** Allstate Identity Protection scores 9.2, while ID Shield scores 7.9. - **Coverage Breadth:** ID Shield is specifically cited for monitoring a wide range of personal information, including medical IDs and professional licenses. ### What are the pros and cons of Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield? Allstate Identity Protection's headline strength is comprehensive support and proactive monitoring, while ID Shield's is broad monitoring coverage including medical and professional IDs. - **Allstate Identity Protection strengths:** Comprehensive support, proactive monitoring, real-time alerts, dedicated fraud resolution team, high ease of setup, and strong customer support. - **Allstate Identity Protection trade-offs:** Some reviewers mention the user interface could be more intuitive and that the wide feature set may be overwhelming. - **ID Shield strengths:** Broad monitoring coverage (including medical IDs and professional licenses), licensed private investigators for identity restoration, and monitoring for all three major credit bureaus. - **ID Shield trade-offs:** Reviewers note the admin portal is difficult to use, perceived value does not always match cost, and customer service can be inconsistent. ### Is Allstate Identity Protection or ID Shield better for small businesses? Allstate Identity Protection is the better fit for small businesses based on higher reviewer satisfaction and ease of setup. - **Allstate Identity Protection:** Reviewers highlight ease of setup, strong support, and comprehensive monitoring as benefits for small business environments. - **ID Shield:** Reviewers mention broad monitoring features but note challenges with the admin portal and perceived value for cost. ### Which Employee Identity Theft Protection platform has better integrations? Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield are at parity for integrations, as neither product has reviewer-cited integration data in recent reviews. - **Allstate Identity Protection:** No reviewer-cited integrations in recent reviews. - **ID Shield:** No reviewer-cited integrations in recent reviews. ### How do Allstate Identity Protection and ID Shield compare on customer support? Allstate Identity Protection outperforms ID Shield on Quality of Support by a margin of 1.3 points (9.2 vs 7.9). - **Allstate Identity Protection:** Reviewers consistently praise the dedicated fraud resolution team and responsive customer support. - **ID Shield:** Reviewers report inconsistent customer service, with some experiencing longer response times and challenges resolving complex cases. ### Which is easier to implement, Allstate Identity Protection or ID Shield? Allstate Identity Protection is easier to implement, with a 0.9-point advantage in Ease of Setup (9.5 vs 8.6). - **Allstate Identity Protection:** Reviewers describe setup as straightforward and easy, with several noting quick onboarding for employees. - **ID Shield:** Reviewers mention that while setup is generally manageable, the admin portal can be difficult to use and configuration may take more time. ### Which product has better Monitoring? Allstate Identity Protection is rated higher for Monitoring, the most frequently mentioned feature across both products' reviews. - **Allstate Identity Protection:** Reviewers highlight proactive monitoring, real-time alerts, and comprehensive coverage for personal and financial information. - **ID Shield:** Reviewers note broad monitoring coverage, including medical IDs and professional licenses, and monitoring for all three major credit bureaus. Alternatives **Allstate Identity Protection Alternatives** ![Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_edcfae5427908321d9423efcad1f8cdc/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions.jpeg "Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions") [ Norton LifeLock Benefit... ](/products/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions/reviews) ![IDX](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_a3c64b81c576dfe657ca1486c909aecd/idx.jpeg "IDX") [ IDX ](/products/idx/reviews) ![Identity Guard](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_2ebe093e124274cd99eb064ef1895d5a/identity-guard.jpg "Identity Guard") [ Identity Guard ](/products/identity-guard/reviews) ![Agency](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/ed60aec5c35fc2bd7597f43a3eed0896/agency-2025-12-16.svg "Agency") [ Agency ](/products/agency-2025-12-16/reviews) **ID Shield Alternatives** ![Identity Guard](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_2ebe093e124274cd99eb064ef1895d5a/identity-guard.jpg "Identity Guard") [ Identity Guard ](/products/identity-guard/reviews) ![Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_edcfae5427908321d9423efcad1f8cdc/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions.jpeg "Norton LifeLock Benefit Solutions") [ Norton LifeLock Benefit... ](/products/norton-lifelock-benefit-solutions/reviews) ![IdentityIQ](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/image/thumb_square/thumb_square_21489edcecccd64b49a016f688fd016d/identityiq.png "IdentityIQ") [ IdentityIQ ](/products/identityiq/reviews) ![Agency](https://images.g2crowd.com/uploads/product/hd_favicon/ed60aec5c35fc2bd7597f43a3eed0896/agency-2025-12-16.svg "Agency") [ Agency ](/products/agency-2025-12-16/reviews) ## Allstate Identity Protection vs ID Shield - Reviewers felt that Allstate Identity Protection meets the needs of their business better than ID Shield. - When comparing quality of ongoing product support, reviewers felt that Allstate Identity Protection is the preferred option. - For feature updates and roadmaps, our reviewers preferred the direction of ID Shield over Allstate Identity Protection.